Controversial opinions on metal

[King Richard]

BLACK WATERPARK!!!!11

 

[CF87]

Oh yeah? Why don't you educate me then smart guy.

Celtic Frost-morbid tales,to mega therion.
Bathory-the return,blood fire death.
Venom-black metal,welcome to hell.
Mercyful Fate-melissa
KD-abigail.

That's pretty much it.

 

[bagdad]

I disagree with all the opinions about closing this thread. I find most of the shit written in here to be absolutely hilarious/enlightening. I lurk these forums a few times a week and always return to see what sort of blasphemous bull shit people post in here.

Anyways... Here's something controversial....


The album Demonic from Testament is very good. Chuck Billy is capable of excellent death metal vocals and the song writing on the album is very creepy. The track Together as One absolutely owns.

 

[-CC-]

^Now thats a trve lvrker right there

Controversial?:

Demilich > Demigod > Convulse

 

[Lateralus14]

Controversial?:

Demigod > Demilich > Convulse

No, not really controversial at all.

 

[-CC-]

For a second there, I really thought you were just quoting the original sentence

 

[The Ozzman]

and this thread is still open.

Moderator fail

 

[King Richard]

Ya I think it'd be more fitting if an Ozzman thread was closed as opposed to just dying out naturally.

 

[Dak]

This thread does the wonderful job of condensing all the Priest-Maiden/Opeth/Metallica-other thrash bands/etc. threads that would inevitably pop up without it.

 

[no country for old wainds]

tbh this is my favourite megathread the other ones are worse. call me old school but i much prefer forums where you get new threads devoted to bands and releases n shit, not these running conversations. i cant really explain why though it's probably an autism thing. unfortunately deron will never make me mod again after i burnt down his local church.

 

[Bitencourt29]

This thread does the wonderful job of condensing all the Priest-Maiden/Opeth/Metallica-other thrash bands/etc. threads that would inevitably pop up without it.

Yeah, agreed.

 

[The Ozzman]

tbh this is my favourite megathread the other ones are worse. call me old school but i much prefer forums where you get new threads devoted to bands and releases n shit, not these running conversations. i cant really explain why though it's probably an autism thing. unfortunately deron will never make me mod again after i burnt down his local church.

That happens at the SMN boards and look at what happened to those.

 

[The Butt]

tbh this is my favourite megathread the other ones are worse. call me old school but i much prefer forums where you get new threads devoted to bands and releases n shit, not these running conversations. i cant really explain why though it's probably an autism thing. unfortunately deron will never make me mod again after i burnt down his local church.

Did you burn a hundred a month?

 

[Thoth-Amon]

Early doesn't always equal better (though more often than not, it does). I prefer mid-discography Dimmu Borgir over new and old Dimmu, for example. I know most people are of opinion "A" (All Dummy Burger sux ballz) or opinion "B" (Stormblast and For All Tid is good, everything else sucks), but I'm secure in my manhood, so I'm not afraid to admit to my preference for ETD, SBD, and PEM.

Agreed... though I think Stormblast is really good too.

 

[Badbird]

Talking about Opeth/Metallica/Death/Other well known bands ruin the forum

I'd be okay with Andy closing the thread. 700 pages is pretty stellar for any thread.

FYP

 

[Omni]

tbh this is my favourite megathread the other ones are worse. call me old school but i much prefer forums where you get new threads devoted to bands and releases n shit, not these running conversations. i cant really explain why though it's probably an autism thing. unfortunately deron will never make me mod again after i burnt down his local church.

Yeah, most of the other megathreads are lame, but this one eliminates a lot of other shitty threads and occasionally contains interesting conversation.

 

[Manic Ferocity]

I'd be in favor of having threads dedicated to individual bands. Let the recommendations forum serve its purpose.

 

[HamburgerBoy]

The album Demonic from Testament is very good. Chuck Billy is capable of excellent death metal vocals and the song writing on the album is very creepy. The track Together as One absolutely owns.

Demonic actually got me into death metal. It has lost some of its allure now that I can tolerate tr00er albums/bands, but I still enjoy it. Definitely better than their 88-92 period.

 

[unknown]

There are threads dedicated to individual bands:

http://www.ultimatemetal.com/forum/general-metal-discussion/552206-gmd-genre-band-directory.html

 

[meaperson333]

I disagree with all the opinions about closing this thread. I find most of the shit written in here to be absolutely hilarious/enlightening. I lurk these forums a few times a week and always return to see what sort of blasphemous bull shit people post in here.

Anyways... Here's something controversial....


The album Demonic from Testament is very good. Chuck Billy is capable of excellent death metal vocals and the song writing on the album is very creepy. The track Together as One absolutely owns.

I loved Demonic.