I figured since I was so impressed with DT and Soilwork's latest albums I should probably check out Arch Enemy's latest record as well. I'd read some reviews of Will To Power and they all seemed pretty down on it, so I was expecting to be disappointed.
I'm pretty baffled though, because for me this is probably the best AE album I've heard. I think it's absolutely fantastic. I didn't really like their first three albums, and there are only a handful of songs from Wages of Sin and Anthems of Rebellion that I really enjoyed (Burning Angel, Ravenous, Shadows and Dust, We Will Rise, Dead Eyes See No Future). Nemesis was the only song I liked off Doomsday Machine (I actually thought that was off Anthems of Rebellion) and their next three albums did nothing for me either.
This one really impressed me though. It's an awesome mix of traditional MDM combined with american Power Metal which works perfectly together. MDM is often PM tinged so it's not a surprise that these two elements merge effectively, but AE did a wonderful job here imo. The criticism this album gets confuses me.
Set Flame To The Night - N/A - just an intro.
The Race - 8.5/10 - this is just a pure MDM song. A blistering opening with vicious vocals and pounding riffs. Awesome guitar solos/melodies at around the 1:50 and 2:50 mark. Fast paced and powerful. Could fit on any old school MDM album and not feel out of place at all.
Blood in the Water - 10/10 - an opening that could have come directly off Wages of Sin or Anthems of Rebellion. Groovy riffs and vocals that fit perfectly with the instruments. More incredible guitar work all across this track. Put this on Wages of Sin or Anthems of Rebellion and nobody would bat an eyelid. It's classic AE at their absolute best. Awesome short guitar solo at 1:56, and more outstanding guitar work at 02:59. Reminds me of something you would have heard on a TJR or Whoracle guitar breakdown. I don't see how anybody who claims to like MDM could do anything but love this song, it's just great.
The World Is Yours - 9.5/10 - another track that starts off like something you'd hear on WoS or AoR. At first it carries on exactly the same path as Blood in the Water, but then the chorus switches to a distinctly power metal flavour before the guitar lets rip with another brief, awesome solo. I mark it slightly below Blood in the Water just because the transition from pure MDM to power metal in the chorus is a little jarring, but I still love it. More great PM sounding guitar work at 02:26, we're then back to the WoS/AoR sound for a minute or so, before the instruments fade out and we get some well placed melodic keys and guitars with whispered vocals, transitioning back into that awesome chorus. Song ends with the guitar taking centre stage and producing some soaring melodies.
The Eagle Flies Alone - 7.5 - OK, so, this song should be another 9 or 9.5 out of 10. Great opening, cool verses, but my big complaint - WTF did they do to the guitars in the chorus? It's a great chorus but for reason beyond my understanding they have completely nerfed the guitar here. It sounds weak as fuck. This sucks. It should have a broad and powerful range, but instead it's like a single wimpy melodic line behind the vocals which seem to be too high in the mix. The melodies across the song also sound slightly too slow. A faster tempo would have made it sound a lot better. This is very disappointing as it drags the song down considerably for me. There is some more great guitar work around the 03:30 mark but it just emphasises how badly the guitars have been mixed into the chorus. What should have been a great song becomes just a good song.
Reason To Believe - 7 - this is the power ballad of the album and features Alissa singing clean for most of it. She's got a good singing voice and the song itself is fine, with some nice 80s power ballad guitar work in the middle, but I'm confused as to why they had her scream/growl the chorus. The entire song should have been clean vocals. The harsh vocals in the chorus contrast too sharply with the slow, melancholic tone of the track. Strange decision. Anyway, it's OK but it loses .5 of a point for unnecessarily switching to growls when the majority of the song is cleans and really should have stayed that way.
Murder Scene - 7.5 - brutal opening with some nice guitar work straight out of the gate. The song as a whole is pretty good MDM, but also quite generic. It's not on the level of The Race or Blood in the Water. A decent, by the books track largely overshadowed by the earlier songs on the album, although as usual there's some outstanding guitar work across the track.
First Day In Hell - 7.5 - similar to the above track, another solid MDM track with good vocals and groovy riffs. Nothing wrong with it, but it feels like a bit of a rehash of previous songs at this point. Nothing new.
Saturnine - N/A - an instrumental intro into the next song. Cool guitar work but too short to rate properly.
Dreams of Retribution - 8.5/10 - I can see a lot of people disliking this one, as this is basically AE going full power metal. Everything about this song is PM, and you know it as soon as the opening riffs play. Personally I think it sounds great, nice and epic with a galloping tempo, an infusion of gothic-tinged keys and soaring power metal riffs. Very nice to my ears, but maybe not so much to people who dislike PM. The only thing I would say is that the song clocks in at 6:40 and probably doesn't need to be that long. It could have been 5:40 or even 4:40 and not really lost anything significant.
My Shadow and I - 6/10 - the weakest song on the album to me. It's similar to Murder Scene and First Day In Hell, but even more generic. As with every song on this album you'll get some great riffs, but there's nothing here that hasn't already been done multiple times on this album.
A Fight I Must Win - 7.5 - similar to Dreams of Retribution but slower and less energetic. More of a mixture of MDM and PM in this one though, where Dreams of Retribution is almost entirely a PM song with screams/growls. It's good but by this point you feel like you've pretty much heard all that this album has to offer.
Overall it's fair to say the album peaks with its first three songs, which are superb. Most of the rest is still very good but not on the same level. Still extremely solid MDM/MDM-PM, but by the time you get to the final two songs it's clear that the band's creativity has been used up and you aren't hearing anything new. Nonetheless personally I think this is an extremely good album with three top tier songs rounded out by a collection of very good to good tracks which in isolation are all very listenable. Guitar work is stellar throughout the album, vocals are on point and sound good on pretty much every tracks. As to be expected with this type of album you don't hear much bass, and the drums support the music on the whole very well. Production is good for the most part, except for The Eagle Flies Alone which they inexplicably fucked up.
8.5/10. On the whole the strongest Arch Enemy album I've ever listened to, having never been able to fully pay attention to their classic albums and largely being disappointed with their post-2003 efforts.