Trying to be heavy just for sake of it is stupid,I want to listen to kickass songs and anthrax have delivered that to me,in saying that I really ain't much metal at all these days,it's so overun with crap these days,I want something new new.
I don't blame you. Yes the 'modern' metal scene is pretty lame. That is why I stick with the new Machine Head, Testament, etc.
I like most of WM, though some of the Choruses get boring and sound too commercialized. The production is almost too 'perfect' sounding that it lacks the crunch and thick guitar tones. But we'll see if it stands the test of time!