ROYAL CARNAGE APRIL MADNESS: Results, pt. 1

[Erik]

128 contestants, 1 winner. The best album ever made, according to the Royal Carnage forum populace:

​

I'm going to compile a list that shows the albums ranked from 1-128 soon. Anyway, let the flaming commence!

 

[J.]

I'm fine with that.

 

[Dev]

RC HAS SHITTY TASTES
















































this or Erik didn't make Pale Folklore win because it would have been too flagrant he had his hands on the contest

 

[Chromatose]

coo'


*eagerly awaits may madness*

 

[NAD]

1st song = unruly
the rest = meh

 

[lurch70]

i can live with this ...

 

[JayKeeley]

I'm going to compile a list that shows the albums ranked from 1-128 soon. Anyway, let the flaming commence!

I can live with the top 4, but yes, it'll be interesting to see all the rankings.

What was the actual difference in votes between Burzum and runner up, Agalloch?

 

[Erik]

13 - 11. 2 votes for Burzum were declared invalid because they were submitted too late.

 

[MFJ]

good, i'm glad with the results.

 

[Demilich]

not bad! i don't know how this beat all those popular old bands, but to me that just means that RC is more levelheaded than a bunch of oldschoolers voting based on nostalgia!

 

[MFJ]

Pale Folklore is 10/10, but Hvis Lyset Tar Oss is WAY beyond it in every way (I think, atleast).

 

[MajestikMøøse]

Amazing. My favorite album ever made the #1. I'm proud of you all.

 

[NAD]

not bad! i don't know how this beat all those popular old bands, but to me that just means that RC is more levelheaded than a bunch of oldschoolers voting based on nostalgia!

hahaha what?! Dude Rust in Peace shits all over this entire list, and I must admit, I have very little nostalgia with that album even if I've been listening to it for well over a decade. That album is just flat out SOLID and nothing more.

I have more nostalgia with Cryptic Writings (first year of college, woo!) than Rust in Peace, simply because I've ALWAYS listened to Rust in Peace, it's been a part of the daily routine for most of my years.

Rust in Peace is one of maybe 5 albums that, objectively speaking, are untouchable.

 

[General Zod]

I've never heard anything by Burzum. I'll check it out, for chuckles and grins if for no other reason. Somehow, I doubt I'll find it superior to "Dreaming Neon Black".

Zod

 

[MajestikMøøse]

you probably won't like it, but who knows?

 

[Demilich]

hahaha what?! Dude Rust in Peace shits all over this entire list, and I must admit, I have very little nostalgia with that album even if I've been listening to it for well over a decade. That album is just flat out SOLID and nothing more.

I have more nostalgia with Cryptic Writings (first year of college, woo!) than Rust in Peace, simply because I've ALWAYS listened to Rust in Peace, it's been a part of the daily routine for most of my years.

Rust in Peace is one of maybe 5 albums that, objectively speaking, are untouchable.

Yea, well that's you, it's fine and all, I'm just glad that RC's general tastes are representative of a variety of tastes, but I didn't even need a tournament to tell me that, so why am I even posting here?

 

[KILL TULLY]

Im not upset by this, but im baffled as to how it beat out the likes of Maiden.


But hey, im wearing my Hvis shirt right now so im a f4nboi as well

 

[Lies and Perfidy]

Burzum is boring.

 

[JayKeeley]

Burzum is boring.

Now, if only you said this at the beginning of the tournament....

 

[Lies and Perfidy]

Yeah. Hindsight, you know?