Royal Carnage: Essential Bands - Part 2

[General Zod]

I'd define it as a band that has made a lasting mark upon metal and appeals to the majority of the people here (or a lesser known band with a fair share fervent defenders on the forum, like Drudkh or Rev. Bizarre), or one that isn't universally appreciated, but inspires frequent debate and discussion (Opeth most obviously).

Well stated.

Zod

 

[JayKeeley]

And if Negura Bunget or Slough Feg were up there, I'd vote them as well. Round 3 perhaps?

And Summoning.

 

[JayKeeley]

Pagan Altar has 7 votes. Rev Bizarre has 6 votes.

Can someone say, "lame"?

By the way, Zod, when you count these up, you should take those that scored 10 and higher (as opposed to 5).

 

[NAD]

yeah reverrend bizarre are pretty lame.

pagan altar though, VOTE. good shitz.

 

[General Zod]

Pagan Altar has 7 votes. Rev Bizarre has 6 votes.

I've never heard a single note by either band.

By the way, Zod, when you count these up, you should take those that scored 10 and higher (as opposed to 5).

10 or more votes, will leave us with at least 20 bands. Plus, I was planning on putting together one last round, to cover my oversights. Do you still want it at 10 or more, or would you like to limit it to the Top ___ (fill in blank) vote getters?

Zod

 

[Nico]

We need one more round, because a top RC list without Slough Feg would be like... wrong.

 

[General Zod]

We need one more round, because a top RC list without Slough Feg would be like... wrong.

Yeah. I think I left these guys out for two reasons. One... personal bias. I never much cared for these guys. Then I saw them live, and I really grew to dislike them. Two... we already had Hammers in the list. One Scalzi band is more than enough for any list (in my estimation). That said, I'll make sure they go in the final round.

Zod

 

[Nico]

As I said in another thread, Morrigan would also do well to be placed in a future round.

 

[Sadguru]

bump

 

[JayKeeley]

15 or more votes are the winners:

Moonsorrow
Opeth
Primordial
Ulver

Round 'em up.

 

[General Zod]

Will do.

Zod