Singing about yourself. Rappers are the worst for it (though that's the least of their many punishing flaws) but there are many metal bands who can't resist having at least one song about themselves or how they're going to "come fuck you up". One of the main dark spots on Iron Maiden's career.
? That song is about an actual Iron Maiden, not the band itself, and it kicks fucking ass. The dark spot would be the 90's.
Ok, time for a long list.
First off, metalcore. I don't like it. There's just something about it...maybe the way all the bands use that gay lacey font, or the way it pretends to be metal...or maybe how it just sucks.
Next off, how every show I go to has way too many metalcore bands playing. Look at this:
Megadeth with In This Moment and The Confession
Amon Amarth with Sonic Syndicate and Thy Will Be Done (who were actually good)
Dragonforce with Killswitch Engage, Chimaira, and He Is Legend
Dragonforce with All That Remains and HORSE the Band
Sounds of the Underground is all metalcore, plus AA, Shadows Fall, and GWAR
And Iron Maiden's last US tour? Openers such as Bullet For My Valentine and Trivium. What the fuck is up with good metal bands touring with shitty metalcore bands? Is it just me?
Next: Packaging
Good: Lyrics, pictures, liner notes about the writing or recording of the album (a la the Sepultura reissues of Arise and Beneath The Remains, or the Megadeth Remasters)
Solid: Lyrics, pictures (a la the Maiden Reissues, which had all the single artwork too - well done)
Shitty: One single band photo, or just the copyright info (a la some of the Anthrax reissues, the Peaceville reissues of the first three At The Gates albums, et)
But best of all - lyrics, photos, background info, and a map of whatever fantasy world you're singing about. See Rhapsody - Legendary Tales to see how it should be done.
Live Performances
Dos:
Kick ass
Interact with the crowd (slapping hands and such)
Play sober
Poll the fans for setlists
Have a nice stage show
Know how to play your songs
Don't:
Suck
Ignore crowd
Play wasted
Create a shitty setlist
Rely on your stage show and crazy lighting to make up for a mediocre performance
Do the emo hop
Have crappy stage moves
Stand in place all night (Maiden gets a pass on this - Dave Murray and Adrian Smith stand in place, but Steve Harris and Bruce Dickinson run around)
Tour with metalcore bands
Set up quickly and then just sit around for 10 minutes (this happened at an Amon Amarth show - the roadies finished in 15 minutes, but the band didn't come on for another 15. I think this has more to do with the management of the venue than the band, but it really annoys me)
Cut your hair but still headbang
Wear your own band shirt
If the entire crowd is sitting down, just leave the stage.
Then there's image
Ok, don't look gay. Just irritating. But don't try to look hardcore and shit. Pictures should look fairly natural. Axes, corpsepaint, and all that bullshit look ridiculous. You're musicians, not clowns (I hope). Not to say there can be no corpsepaint, just...gets kind of ridiculous.
However, if the picture complements the music (i.e. Turisas band photos), go for it.
The main rule of image is: NO FUCKING EYESHADOW.
Lyrics:
Self absorbed lyrics are boring. I don't care about your fucking issues. Unless you actually mean it. And then you walk the thin line of becoming emo. So basically, self absorbed sentimental lyrics are tough to pull off. Better off singing about battles n shit.
Gruesomely violent lyrics are A) boring and B) gross. Why can't there be a brutal death metal band that uses typical hard rock lyrics about girls and cars, except with a death grunt?
Fantasy lyrics - remember, kids, if you're riding a dragon, you're gay.
Cover art: It shouldn't look shitty. All I have to say.
Number of tracks on an album: Should be 8 to 10, but don't write filler to inflate it.
Length of a solo: Should be as short as possible, because solos are only fun for the guitarist
Bonus tracks: NO MORE JAPANESE BONUS TRACKS! THEY JUST GET PIRATED ONLINE!
Covers: Please, do more covers! Covers are great. I love covers. Bands don't do enough of them. Just...it would be nice if they picked songs that people would be familiar with.
Selling out:
Is defined as: Making an alteration in the style of music, image, or whatever of a band for the sole purpose of making more money.
Examples:
Metallica - S/t (Load and Reload weren't really sell-outs - they were just doing their thing)
Megadeth - Everything between Youthanasia and The System Has Failed
Bashing religion for no real reason:
Gets really boring. Just put an inverted crucifix in some artwork and that's enough. We get - you play metal, therefore you wish to eat Jesus' entrails. Get in line.
Calling yourself KFK:
Does that stand for Kerry Fucking King? cause it sounds like Kentucky Fried Koalas or something. Who said you get to give yourself a nickname? And why would you pick "fucking" as a nickname?