Yeah, it's not the tuning is weird in the sense that it's not standard tuning. There were just notes that sounded flat. I've started using an open d6 and actually I think I'm going to drop it to open c6 for this EP I'm recording this fall. Really, really diggin' the deep tones that it gives me.
But still, just like my own
total failure at recording, I think those songs still have value. Mine laid out a good blue print. The problem is that the recording sounds shitty, lifeless and fake. Because it's basically shitty, lifeless and fake.
So the people who really give it a chance say "Yeah it's great, shame about the recording though...." And I think I've fairly well proven that by putting out Suicide Hymn which has had a much better reaction.
BTW: I'd love to hear the record you recorded. You should upload it.
NP: More October Falls
Ok. I listened the song, first plain EQ, then with different settings.
About the mix: I can hear everything, just the bass is under the average mix.
The sound: the drum sound can be improved but it's ok. I don't know about your tastes on drum sounds but this is why I feel it needs:
The cymbals need to be 'thinner', so they can be heard clearly without adding any gain. the 'body' of the cymbals can be added by a little reverb. The toms need a little more definition. The snare is really 'dark' and compressed to my ears.
About the programming: As a drummer, I find a problem mainly on the velocities and some fills. Did u use some pattern given by the software? the hi-hat strokes under the blastbeats sections sounds weird or, IMO, it gives a 'slowing down' feeling, being heard just half of the strokes compared with blastbeats. The snare sound really flat/plain. The velocities of a real drummer change a lot on fills, single strokes and blastbeats. Unless it's an ultra triggered drumkit, no snare hit sound exactly like any other and the aim usually is to make it 'real'. Then again, I dunno about your preferences, but I like the style from Richard Christy, Asgeir, Sean Reinert and such and I try to emulate some of their dynamics at playing.
Bass: I can 'sense' it, but not hear it clearly. If you wanna keep it in that way just to add 'heaviness' and that bottom low to complement the drums and give shape to the kicks, it's ok. I wonder about some fretless bass on the mellow parts... would sound amazing.
Guitars: The playing is ok. the acoustic ones sounds fine. I had a feeling that you don't use a L/R-100% panning on the mellow parts. The distorsion can be improved IMO. Do you mic an amp or are you using a Vst/Rtas software?
Vocals: growling very good. The cleans can improve a lot, but it's not bad at all. Maybe duplicating the tracks can do the trick. Akerfeldt, Ihsahn - on Emperor at least - and others seems to use a trick to give more room to the vocals, adding 1 extra take of every vocal track with a shitload of reverb but very low on the mix, so it add ambience and a little 'chorus' feeling. Vortex used and abused of it with Dimmu.
Again, I liked the song.
The production value can kill a record. I recall that I found a remastered version of Ulver's Vargnatt and it really kick ass. It's a shame that the demo was released with such a poor production.