Vegard Pompey
ALLY TO GOOD, NIGHTMARE TO YOU
@Vegard Pompey Our Final Fantasy lists are quite similar. I haven't met many other people who like Final Fantasy 12 as much as I do! Many would have 10 in there, but I find it to be kind of overrated yet still good.
I finished FF12 for the first time a few months ago (not the first time I played it though) and I recently started playing it again, it just keeps pulling me back. (I also play the international version which further adds to the replay value with its job system) It's such a relaxing game to play, I love just exploring its beautiful world and letting the gambits do the work. I love that getting in a fight means I can put down the controller for a minute, means I can easily eat while playing which is cool. On the downside the story is kinda shit and the music isn't that great (as far as non-Uematsu soundtracks go, 13 has it beat by a good margin imo)
I also replayed 10 recently (yes I may have been binging FF lately) and I liked it more than I remembered and almost considered putting it in my #5 spot. It's gorgeous (esp. the remaster), the battle system is elegant and the story is... kinda good?
When you replay it with the knowledge that the entire quest is a suicide mission many scenes in the game take on a more melancholic tone and you realize the whole point of the game is about putting on a brave face when confronted with tragedy (that and also sticking it to institutionalized religion) and it makes the upbeat tone of the game more palatable and even parts like the infamous laughing scene become poignant. That said it's still a bit too cheerful for me and I'd take the oppressively melancholic atmosphere of 6/7 over it any day.