Vote: Royal Carnage 2006 March Madness

Status
Not open for further replies.

General Zod

Ruler of Australia
May 1, 2001
14,192
36
48
New Jersey
www.facebook.com
First off, at JK's suggestion, all bands who reached the 2005 Final Four (Agalloch, Burzum, Enslaved, and 2005 Champion, Bathory) were removed from this year's tournament. I used a web-based random number generator to assign numbers to each band. The bands were then matched against each other based on those numerical assignments.

A few guidelines for voting:

1 - please vote for one band in each match-up listed, in all four bracket
2 - if you're not familiar with either band ina given match-up, don't vote
3 - there's no one ideal way to determine who to vote for (strength of last release, strength of complete discography, best album artwork, the level of kvltedness, etc.), so vote for who ever you want to vote for.

Bracket #1
Obituary vs. Meshuggah
Judas Priest vs. Blind Guardian
Ulver vs. Nevermore
Hammers of Misfortune vs. Asphyx
Opeth vs. Metallica
Kataklysm vs. Blood Red Throne
Thyrfing vs. Negura Bunget
Gojira vs. Anathema

Bracket #2
The Crown vs. Falkenbach
Dark Tranquillity vs. Amon Amarth
Novembre vs. Melechesh
Isis vs. Black Sabbath
Overkill vs. Morbid Angel
King Diamond/Merciful Fate vs. Carcass
Testament vs. Emperor
Destroyer 666 vs. Akercocke

Bracket #3
Orphaned Land vs. Moonsorrow
Kayo Dot vs. Blut Aus Nord
Nile vs. Manegarm
Immortal vs. At the Gates
Pink Floyd vs. My Dying Bride
Kreator vs. Carpathian Forrest
Tool vs. Neurosis
Graveland vs. Anthrax

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom vs. Megadeth
Iron Maiden vs. Behemoth
The Lord Weird Slough Feg vs. Finntroll
Dimmu Borgir vs. Amorphis
Primordial vs. Naglfar
Led Zeppelin vs. Death
Slayer vs. Drudkh
Deathspell Omega vs. Aeturnus

Zod
 
Bracket #1
Obituary
Judas Priest
Ulver
Hammers of Misfortune
Metallica
Blood Red Throne
Negura Bunget
Gojira

Bracket #2
The Crown
Amon Amarth
Black Sabbath
Morbid Angel
Carcass
Testament
Akercocke

Bracket #3

Blut Aus Nord
Immortal
Pink Floyd
Kreator
Tool
Anthrax

Bracket #4
Megadeth
Iron Maiden
The Lord Weird Slough Feg
Dimmu Borgir
Primordial
Death
Slayer


DAMN ... some good matchups this time around ... this is goign to be tough
 
Bracket #1
Meshuggah
Judas Priest
Nevermore
Hammers of Misfortune
Metallica

Negura Bunget
Anathema

Bracket #2
Falkenbach
Dark Tranquillity

Isis
Morbid Angel
Carcass
Emperor
Akercocke

Bracket #3
Moonsorrow
Blut Aus Nord
Nile
Immortal
My Dying Bride

Neurosis
Graveland

Bracket #4
Megadeth
Iron Maiden
The Lord Weird Slough Feg
Amorphis
Primordial
Death
Slayer
Deathspell Omega

Damn you . . . on some of those. What the hell is up with Pink Floyd and Led Zepplin? I voted 'em out just to get this down to metal.
 
Bracket #1
Obituary
Blind Guardian
Nevermore
Hammers of Misfortune
Metallica
Kataklysm
Negura Bunget
Anathema

Bracket #2
Falkenbach
Dark Tranquillity
Novembre
Isis
Overkill
Carcass
Emperor
Destroyer 666

Bracket #3
Moonsorrow
Blut Aus Nord
Nile
At the Gates
My Dying Bride
Kreator
Tool
Graveland

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom
Iron Maiden
Finntroll
Amorphis
Primordial
Death
Drudkh
Aeturnus
 
Obituary vs. Meshuggah
Judas Priest vs. Blind Guardian
Ulver vs. Nevermore
Hammers of Misfortune vs. Asphyx
Opeth vs. Metallica
Kataklysm vs. Blood Red Throne
Thyrfing vs. Negura Bunget
Gojira vs. Anathema

Bracket #2
The Crown vs. Falkenbach
Dark Tranquillity vs. Amon Amarth
Novembre vs. Melechesh
Isis vs. Black Sabbath
Overkill vs. Morbid Angel
King Diamond/Merciful Fate vs. Carcass
Testament vs. Emperor
Destroyer 666 vs. Akercocke

Bracket #3
Orphaned Land vs. Moonsorrow
Kayo Dot vs. Blut Aus Nord
Nile vs. Manegarm
Immortal vs. At the Gates
Pink Floyd vs. My Dying Bride
Kreator vs. Carpathian Forrest
Tool vs. Neurosis
Graveland vs. Anthrax

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom vs. Megadeth
Iron Maiden vs. Behemoth
The Lord Weird Slough Feg vs. Finntroll
Dimmu Borgir vs. Amorphis
Primordial vs. Naglfar
Led Zeppelin vs. Death
Slayer vs. Drudkh
Deathspell Omega vs. Aeturnus
 
Bracket #1
Obituary
Judas Priest
Nevermore
Hammers of Misfortune
Opeth
Blood Red Throne
Thyrfing
Anathema

Bracket #2
Falkenbach
Amon Amarth
Novembre
Black Sabbath
Overkill
King Diamond/Merciful Fate
Testament
Destroyer 666

Bracket #3
Moonsorrow
Blut Aus Nord
Manegarm
At the Gates
My Dying Bride
Carpathian Forrest
Neurosis
Anthrax

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom
Iron Maiden
The Lord Weird Slough Feg
Dimmu Borgir
Primordial
Death
Slayer
Aeturnus
 
Bracket #1
Meshuggah
Blind Guardian
Nevermore
Hammers of Misfortune
Metallica
(NEITHER) Kataklysm vs. Blood Red Throne
(NEITHER) Thyrfing vs. Negura Bunget
(NEITHER) Gojira vs. Anathema

Bracket #2
(NEITHER) The Crown vs. Falkenbach
(NEITHER) Dark Tranquillity vs. Amon Amarth
Novembre
Isis
Overkill
(NEITHER) King Diamond/Merciful Fate vs. Carcass
Testament
(NEITHER) Destroyer 666 vs. Akercocke

Bracket #3
Orphaned Land
Kayo Dot
(NEITHER) Nile vs. Manegarm
(NEITHER) Immortal vs. At the Gates
(NEITHER) Pink Floyd vs. My Dying Bride
(NEITHER) Kreator vs. Carpathian Forrest
Neurosis
Anthrax

Bracket #4
Megadeth
(NEITHER) Iron Maiden vs. Behemoth
The Lord Weird Slough Feg
Amorphis
(NEITHER) Primordial vs. Naglfar
Death
(NEITHER) Slayer vs. Drudkh
(NEITHER) Deathspell Omega vs. Aeturnus

I don't know why I bother voting. A third of the bands I've never listened to, and another third are bands I don't care much for.
 
Bracket #1
Obituary
Judas Priest
Nevermore
Asphyx (tough, tough one to call)
Opeth
Blood Red Throne
Thyrfing
Gojira

Bracket #2
The Crown
Amon Amarth (another real tough one)
Melechesh
Black Sabbath
Morbid Angel
King Diamond/Merciful Fate
Emperor (jeez, the first round matchups are good ones)
Destroyer 666

Bracket #3
Moonsorrow (Damn your random numbered matchups!!)
Blut Aus Nord
Manegarm
Immortal
Pink Floyd
Carpathian Forrest
Neurosis
Anthrax

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom
Iron Maiden
Slough Feg
Amorphis
Primordial (Grrrrr.....)
Death (Sumofabich!!!)
Slayer
Deathspell Omega

Great work Greg. Excellent matchups. Some real tossups in there.
 
Bracket #1
Obituary vs. Meshuggah
Judas Priest vs. Blind Guardian
Ulver vs. Nevermore
Hammers of Misfortune vs. Asphyx
Opeth vs. Metallica
Kataklysm vs. Blood Red Throne
Thyrfing vs. Negura Bunget
Gojira vs. Anathema

Bracket #2
The Crown vs. Falkenbach
Dark Tranquillity vs. Amon Amarth
Novembre vs. Melechesh
Isis vs. Black Sabbath
Overkill vs. Morbid Angel
King Diamond/Merciful Fate vs. Carcass
Testament vs. Emperor
Deströyer 666 vs. Akercocke

Bracket #3
Orphaned Land vs. Moonsorrow
Kayo Dot vs. Blut Aus Nord
Nile vs. Manegarm
Immortal vs. At the Gates
Pink Floyd vs. My Dying Bride
Kreator vs. Carpathian Forrest
Tool vs. Neurosis
Graveland vs. Anthrax

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom vs. Megadeth
Iron Maiden vs. Behemoth
The Lord Weird Slough Feg vs. Finntroll
Dimmu Borgir vs. Amorphis (HAHAHAHAHA...)
Primordial vs. Naglfar
Led Zeppelin vs. Death
Slayer vs. Drudkh
Deathspell Omega vs. Aeturnus
 
Bracket #1
Obituary
Judas Priest
Ulver
Asphyx
Metallica
Blood Red Throne
Negura Bunget
Anathema

Bracket #2
Falkenbach
Dark Tranquillity
Bathory (i.e. neither)
Black Sabbath
Overkill
King Diamond/Merciful Fate (i'm not sure i agree that these are one item but w/e)
Emperor
Destroyer 666

Bracket #3
Moonsorrow
Blut Aus Nord
Nile
At the Gates
My Dying Bride
Kreator
Neurosis
Graveland

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom
Iron Maiden
The Lord Weird Slough Feg
Amorphis
Primordial
Death
Slayer (this pairing needs to fuck off)
Aeturnus
 
Nate The Great said:
What the hell is up with Pink Floyd and Led Zepplin? I voted 'em out just to get this down to metal.
I didn't want this to be "my tournament". So, I used the feedback that people gave me in previous threads. And some folks wanted some non-Metal bands, with crossover appeal, in the tournament.
Erik said:
King Diamond/Merciful Fate (i'm not sure i agree that these are one item but w/e)
I paired it that way last year as well, and no one said anything.

Zod
 
Bracket #1
Obituary
Judas Priest
Ulver
Hammers of Misfortune vs. Asphyx
Metallica
Kataklysm vs. Blood Red Throne
Negura Bunget
Gojira

Bracket #2
The Crown vs. Falkenbach
Dark Tranquillity vs. Amon Amarth
Novembre vs. Melechesh
Black Sabbath
Morbid Angel
. Carcass
Testament
Destroyer 666

Bracket #3
Orphaned Land vs. Moonsorrow
Kayo Dot
Nile vs. Manegarm
Immortal
Pink Floyd
Kreator
Neurosis
Anthrax

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom
Iron Maiden
The Lord Weird Slough Feg vs. Finntroll
Amorphis
Primordial
Led Zeppelin
Slayer
Deathspell Omega vs. Aeturnus
 
Bracket #1
Obituary
Judas Priest
Nevermore
Hammers of Misfortune
Metallica (tough one)
Blood Red Throne
Thyrfing
Gojira

Bracket #2
Amon Amarth (another tough one)
Novembre
Isis
Overkill
King Diamond/Merciful Fate
Akercocke

Bracket #3
Moonsorrow (another tough one)
Immortal
Pink Floyd
Kreator
Tool
Anthrax

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom (yet another tough one)
Iron Maiden (I considered voting for Behemoth just to make Gugs and JK's head explode)
Amorphis
Primordial
Led Zeppelin
Drudkh (easy as pie)

Zod
 
Bracket #1
Obituary
Judas Priest
Nevermore
Hammers of Misfortune
Opeth

Negura Bunget
Gojira

Bracket #2
The Crown
Dark Tranquillity
Melechesh
Black Sabbath
Overkill
King Diamond/Merciful Fate
Testament
Destroyer 666

Bracket #3
Moonsorrow
Kayo Dot
Nile
Immortal
Pink Floyd
Kreator
Tool
Anthrax

Bracket #4
Megadeth
Iron Maiden
The Lord Weird Slough Feg
Amorphis
Primordial
Led Zeppelin
Drudkh
Deathspell Omega
 
Bracket #1
Judas Priest
Ulver
Hammers of Misfortune
Metallica
Negura Bunget
Gojira

Bracket #2
Falkenbach
Amon Amarth
Melechesh
Black Sabbath
Morbid Angel
King Diamond/Merciful Fate
Testament
Destroyer 666

Bracket #3
Orphaned Land
Immortal
Kreator
Tool
Anthrax

Bracket #4
Megadeth
Iron Maiden
The Lord Weird Slough Feg
Amorphis
Primordial
Slayer
Deathspell Omega
 
Bracket #1
Obituary
Judas Priest
Ulver
Asphyx
Metallica
Blood Red Throne
Negura Bunget
Anathema

Bracket #2
Falkenbach
Amon Amarth
Melechesh
Black Sabbath
Overkill
King Diamond/Merciful Fate
Testament vs. Emperor
Destroyer 666

Bracket #3
Moonsorrow
Kayo Dot vs. Blut Aus Nord
Nile
Immortal
Pink Floyd vs. My Dying Bride
Kreator
Tool vs. Neurosis
Graveland

Bracket #4
Megadeth
Iron Maiden
The Lord Weird Slough Feg
Dimmu Borgir vs. Amorphis
Primordial
Death
Slayer
Deathspell Omega
 
Status
Not open for further replies.