Vote: Royal Carnage 2006 March Madness

[General Zod]

I won't get a chance to add all of this up until this evening, when I get home from work. If someone is bored at work and wants to do it, knock yourself out.

Zod

 

[MetalNations]

.....knock yourself out.

Zod

That would hurt.

 

[JayKeeley]

If someone is bored

Well, you came to the right place motherfucker!

EDIT: But I'm not bored because I'm busy working, see? So someone tally this shit and we'll take it to the next round.

 

[Erik]

i've tallied the votes for you zod

the winner is bathory in all pairings

 

[JayKeeley]

and the runner up was bathory

 

[Dark One]

i've tallied the votes for you zod

the winner is bathory in all pairings

The one dead horse that can't be beat enough.

 

[Dick Sirloin]

Youre all living in the fuckin past

 

[MadeInNewJersey]

Ok fine, here's the tallies:

Bracket #1
Obituary 23 vs. Meshuggah 10
Judas Priest 25 vs. Blind Guardian 10
Ulver 26 vs. Nevermore 13
Hammers of Misfortune 19 vs. Asphyx 9
Opeth 16 vs. Metallica 21
Kataklysm 9 vs. Blood Red Throne 17
Thyrfing 7 vs. Negura Bunget 30
Gojira 11 vs. Anathema 19

Bracket #2
The Crown 12 vs. Falkenbach 19
Dark Tranquillity 15 vs. Amon Amarth 20
Novembre 9 vs. Melechesh 22
Isis 15 vs. Black Sabbath 22
Overkill 13 vs. Morbid Angel 22
King Diamond/Mercyful Fate 17 vs. Carcass 18
Testament 9 vs. Emperor 27
Destroyer 666 29 vs. Akercocke 7

Bracket #3
Orphaned Land 9 vs. Moonsorrow 23
Kayo Dot 13 vs. Blut Aus Nord 20
Nile 20 vs. Manegarm 7
Immortal 25 vs. At the Gates 12
Pink Floyd 21 vs. My Dying Bride 13
Kreator 20 vs. Carpathian Forest 9
Tool 15 vs. Neurosis 18
Graveland 19 vs. Anthrax 16

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom 20 vs. Megadeth 16
Iron Maiden 30 vs. Behemoth 7
The Lord Weird Slough Feg 23 vs. Finntroll 9
Dimmu Borgir 10 vs. Amorphis 26
Primordial 34 vs. Naglfar 4
Led Zeppelin 14 vs. Death 20
Slayer 18 vs. Drudkh 19
Deathspell Omega 25 vs. Aeturnus 9

Someone might want to re-count Slayer vs. Drudkh and King Diamond/Mercyful Fate vs. Carcass, as they were decided by a single vote each.

 

[Dick Sirloin]

Ok fine, here's the tallies:

Bracket #1
Novembers Doom 20[/B] vs. Megadeth 16
Led Zeppelin 14 vs. Death 20

These are the only ones that made me sad.

 

[MadeInNewJersey]

they made me sad too

 

[Hell Mike]

How many participants? about 40?

 

[Dark One]

My round 1 surprises (not in terms of the winner, but in terms of the lopsided nature of the battles):

Thyrfing 7 vs. Negura Bunget 30

Testament 9 vs. Emperor 27

Nile 20 vs. Manegarm 7

 

[MadeInNewJersey]

How many participants? about 40?

ballpark it seemed, yes

everyone voted in the Primordial thrashing of Naglfar, btw

 

[Hell Mike]

OK so 38 then, thought maybe a few more if not everyone voted everywhere

 

[MadeInNewJersey]

that was an ass-kicking, lol

 

[Dark One]

Primordial absolutely transcends the immediate gratification of a band like Naglfar - though what Naglfar does, they do quite well.

 

[Hell Mike]

nemtheanga

 

[Dark One]

indeed

 

[MadeInNewJersey]

I'm not surprised at all.

Primoridal = worshipped here, and genuinely passionate, original band

Naglfar = very few *love* and while they do what they do very well, they're nowhere near the "unique" band that Primordial is and has become

 

[General Zod]

Gugs... you fucking rule. I hate counting up that 1st Round. I double-checked your counts. I also had Drudkh topping Slayer 19/18. I had Carcass over KD/MF 19/16.

On to Round 2.

Zod