Vote: Royal Carnage 2006 March Madness

[MadeInNewJersey]

those were surprisingly easy for, save Amon Amarth over Dark Tranquillity, and Slayer over Drudkh (sorry Drudkh, just not yet).

 

[Doom]

Yeah, Amon Amarth and DT was the trickiest one for me too.

 

[Trylakos]

Bracket #1
Obituary
Blind Guardian
Ulver
Negura Bunget

Bracket #2
Falkenbach
Amon Amarth
Isis
Morbid Angel
Carcass
Emperor
Akercocke

Bracket #3
Moonsorrow
Blut Aus Nord
Nile
Immortal
Pink Floyd
Kreator
Graveland

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom
Iron Maiden
Amorphis
Primordial
Death
Drudkh
Deathspell Omega

 

[J.]

Bracket #1
Obituary
Blind Guardian
Ulver
Asphyx (hmm, classic old school death or average buffet metal. let me think...)
Opeth
Kataklysm vs. Blood Red Throne (not familiar with Kata, but BRT is meh)
Negura Bunget
Gojira vs. Anathema (not familiar with the whale band)

Bracket #2
Falkenbach
Amon Amarth
Melechesh
Black Sabbath (that's just wrong)
Overkill vs. Morbid Angel
Carcass
Emperor
Destroyer 666

Bracket #3
Moonsorrow
Blut Aus Nord (both blow equally but BAN less so)
Manegarm (going off the strength of each band's latest)
Immortal
My Dying Bride
Kreator vs. Carpathian Forrest (dunno)
Neurosis
Graveland

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom
Behemoth
Finntroll
Amorphis
Primordial
Death
Drudkh
Aeturnus (i know who should win, but new school will overcome probably)

 

[Dark One]

What's the toughest choice so far? For me it's Orphaned Land vs. Moonsorrow, to the point where I knew most people would vote for Moonsorrow anyway so I went with the underdog. Either way, 'tis all good.

That was mine as well. Absolutely love both bands, but in the end I went with the band that I'm in the mood for the most often.

 

[J.]

i was just going to say if you vote for behemoth over iron maiden you must be either henrikmain or gay

oh wait

Even worse is all the peeps voting Anthrax over Graveland. :zombie:

 

[Dick Sirloin]

Bracket #1
Obituary vs. Meshuggah
Judas Priest vs. Blind Guardian
Ulver vs. Nevermore
Hammers of Misfortune vs. Asphyx
Opeth vs. Metallica
Kataklysm vs. Blood Red Throne
Thyrfing vs. Negura Bunget
Gojira vs. Anathema

Bracket #2
The Crown vs. Falkenbach
Dark Tranquillity vs. Amon Amarth
Novembre vs. Melechesh
Isis vs. Black Sabbath
Overkill vs. Morbid Angel
King Diamond/Mercyful Fate vs. Carcass
Testament vs. Emperor
Destroyer 666 vs. Akercocke

Bracket #3
Orphaned Land vs. Moonsorrow
Kayo Dot vs. Blut Aus Nord
Nile vs. Manegarm
Immortal vs. At the Gates
Pink Floyd vs. My Dying Bride
Kreator vs. Carpathian Forrest
Tool vs. Neurosis
Graveland vs. Anthrax

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom vs. Megadeth
Iron Maiden vs. Behemoth
The Lord Weird Slough Feg vs. Finntroll
Dimmu Borgir vs. Amorphis
Primordial vs. Naglfar
Led Zeppelin vs. Death
Slayer vs. Drudkh
Deathspell Omega vs. Aeturnus

Zod

Pink Floyd + Led Zeppelin + Black Sabbath + Iron Maiden = this is unfair

 

[JayKeeley]

I didn't even vote in the Pink Floyd and Led Zep matchups. Why didn't we just throw in The Clash and Joy Division while we're at it.

 

[JayKeeley]

I was going to comment on people voting for Drudkh over Slayer and then noticed this:

Drudkh (easy as pie)

Zod

 

[Thanatopsis123]

Bracket #1
Meshuggah
Ulver
Opeth
Blood Red Throne
Negura Bunget
Anathema

Bracket #2
The Crown
Amon Amarth
Melechesh
Isis
Morbid Angel
Emperor
Destroyer 666

Bracket #3
Moonsorrow
Blut Aus Nord
Nile
Immortal
My Dying Bride
Tool
Graveland

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom
Behemoth
Finntroll
Amorphis
Primordial
Death
Drudkh
Deathspell Omega

Edit: Where was Edge of Sanity? I was hoping to see them do better this year.

 

[JayKeeley]

So can we tally the votes now?

 

[General Zod]

I was going to comment on people voting for Drudkh over Slayer and then noticed this:

It's not my fault Slayer sucks ass.

So can we tally the votes now?

I figure I'll let it run 48 hours. Give folks a chance and tally up Wednesday morning. Unless you don't think 48 hours is necessary.

Zod

NP: Slumber - Conflict

 

[Crimson Velvet]

Bracket #1
Obituary
Blind Guardian
Ulver

Metallica

Negura Bunget
Anathema

Bracket #2
The Crown
Dark Tranquillity
Novembre
Black Sabbath
Morbid Angel
Carcass
Emperor
Destroyer 666

Bracket #3



Immortal
My Dying Bride
Kreator

Graveland

Bracket #4
November's Doom
Iron Maiden

Dimmu Borgir
Primordial
Death
Slayer
Deathspell Omega

 

[JayKeeley]

I figure I'll let it run 48 hours. Give folks a chance and tally up Wednesday morning. Unless you don't think 48 hours is necessary.

Nah, 48 hours is good.

 

[MajestikMøøse]

I love how my band suggestions for this, which were not at all unusual and frequent listens for many of the forumers here were completely ignored.

 

[Erik]

also, mine

BATHORY

 

[Climb Thar Hill]

Bracket #1
Obituary
Judas Priest
Nevermore
Hammers of Misfortune
Metallica
Kataklysm
Negura Bunget
Anathema

Bracket #2
The Crown
Amon Amarth
Novembre
Black Sabbath
Overkill
King Diamond/Merciful Fate
Emperor
Destroyer 666

Bracket #3
Orphaned Land
Blut Aus Nord
Manegarm
At the Gates
Pink Floyd
Kreator
Tool
Graveland

Bracket #4
Novembers Doom
IBehemoth
Finntroll
Amorphis
Primordial
Death
Drudkh
Aeturnus

 

[Thanatopsis123]

I love how my band suggestions for this, which were not at all unusual and frequent listens for many of the forumers here were completely ignored.

Mine were too.

 

[MadeInNewJersey]

I still fail to see how anyone could vote Behemoth over Iron Maiden.

 

[NAD]

There was a suggestion box?