Controversial opinions on metal

[mdmatt4ever]

what the fuck?

if you don't like this, then you don't like thrash metal:

without paul or steve singing exodus sounds like dozens of other thrash bands out there right now. sometimes having somone with a distinct voice that maybe not the greatest is better than someone who has a voice considered "normal" for a genre of music. in this case dukes sounds like dozens of other singers out there and its hurting exodus

 

[HamburgerBoy]

It would still sound like dozens of other thrash bands' music even with Baloff or Zetro.

 

[RelentlessOblivion]

moving away from the thrash talk for a minute, if Iced Earth had a GOOD singer they would be perhaps the best power metal band out there, your thoughts?

 

[HamburgerBoy]

They've had plenty of good singers. That's the one thing they haven't lacked in, debut aside.

 

[KafkaX]

Steering away from the Iced Earth discussion because its been over-discussed...

Been listening to a lot of Bolt Thrower lately, getting excited for MDF next year and they are seriously the most prolific Death Metal act around. Album after album, everything theyve released has been fucking stellar. The only other current Death Metal band I could lump with their track record would be Immolation, but I dont even think they match up to Bolt Thrower...

I cant think of another current Death Metal band that has such an impressive track record.

 

[mutantllama]

^The Chasm

 

[Lateralus14]

I'd rather have a couple of monolithic albums ala Morbid Angel/Incantation than a track record of pretty above average stuff though.

 

[Mort Divine]

^The Chasm

This.

The Chasm blows Bolt Thrower and Immolation out of the water.

The last 3 Immolation albums have been mediocre with Harnessing Ruin being bad.

Bolt Thrower hasn't released anything bad, but nothing outside of Realm of Chaos sticks out as incredible. They're just consistently putting out good albums.

The Chasm has been consistently releasing stellar albums.

 

[PhlegethonVeins]

They've had plenty of good singers. That's the one thing they haven't lacked in, debut aside.

.

 

[Krow]

I don't really think The Chasm blows Bolt Thrower out of the water.

I love The Chasm and they've never released anything bad, but they're truly a band I have to be in the mood to listen to. I will always listen to Bolt Thrower more because their version of death metal is death metal candy. It flat out kicks ass and its easy to listen to.

 

[King Richard]

im not going to listen to a band that speaks mexican

fuck off wit dat shitz

 

[KafkaX]

^The Chasm

The Chasm blows Bolt Thrower and Immolation out of the water.

The last 3 Immolation albums have been mediocre with Harnessing Ruin being bad.

Ive never really been able to get on The Chasm train, everytime Ive listened to them it doesnt do much for me... ::ducks::

I will always listen to Bolt Thrower more because their version of death metal is death metal candy. It flat out kicks ass and its easy to listen to.

Well said.

 

[RelentlessOblivion]

They've had plenty of good singers. That's the one thing they haven't lacked in, debut aside.

In what reality is Matt Barlow a good singer? he's terrible, an improvement on the vocalist on Night Of The Stormrider but still dreadful, the only good singer they've had was Tim "Ripper" Owens but of course by then they'd become poor musically so he was never going to last

Chris Poland, best guitar player to associate with Megadeth, your thoughts?

 

[Umodian]

Chris Poland, best guitar player to associate with Megadeth, your thoughts?

Yep. One of my favorite guitar players, love his style. His solo work is also great, especially 'Return to Metalopolis' but also his work with Ohm and Damn the Machine.

 

[PhlegethonVeins]

In what reality is Matt Barlow a good singer? he's terrible, an improvement on the vocalist on Night Of The Stormrider but still dreadful

 

[A1a23]

Yeah Bolt Thrower is definitely more straight forward death metal and much easier to get into. Both have flawless discographies though. Definitely enjoying The Chasm more atm.

 

[Blind Guardian]

Diabolical Conquest is the best The Chasm album. Even though it's technically Incantation.

 

[ASD]

 

[Blind Guardian]

Yeah I had to add the Incantation stuff there so no one thought I was serious. I have a point though, that album gathers the best elements of both bands.

 

[Einherjar86]

In what reality is Matt Barlow a good singer? he's terrible, an improvement on the vocalist on Night Of The Stormrider but still dreadful, the only good singer they've had was Tim "Ripper" Owens but of course by then they'd become poor musically so he was never going to last

I actually agree with this. Barlow, in my opinion, has too melodramatic of an approach; akin to Mark Vanderbilt when he used to sing for Kamelot. I prefer Owens.