I'm the only ones who disagrees.
Do you have everyone else on ignore? There were at least 5 or 6 of us who disagreed.
This is overall a stupid thing to be arguing over because (as far as I've found) for a good number of people who listen to black metal (and black metal's children/bastardizations), it represents something fruity and personal for them. It's also not necessarily a matter of either or, since there is no way in heaven that a person would listen to, say, Mercyful Fate and later Burzum for the same reasons.
I'm going to take this bullshit further and make up a few categories at will
A) "It's Fun To Be Evil And Satanic" - Mercyful Fate, Watain, Venom
B) "It's Not Easy Being A 1337 Blond Person" - Burzum, Grand Belial's Key, Graveland
C) "God I'm So Depressed" - Lantlos, Misere Luminis, Anti
D) "Play Me During Yoga" - Alcest, Drudkh, Agalloch
E) "Insane (Sounding) and Gimmicky" - Silencer, Dark Tribe, Pyha