Still can't play any of them worth a damn, but at least my mediocrity is versatile.
Yep, sounds familiar, except for the "versatile". But what the heck, I'm too old to apologize for doing what I like. Anyone having a band and performing their own material is welcome to make fun of me the same way a proper painter might laugh at people (most of them being women of my age, I presume) that amuse themselves with those "coloring books for adults" that are all over the place, but uncreative as it may be, I simply enjoy learning songs that I dig. Besides, it's good exercise for brain and fingers, forces me to learn stuff I wouldn't come up with by myself, and what's more, I've noticed long ago that figuring out what's actually happening in a song leads me to a more profound appreciation of it.
Anyway, funny timing for bumping up this thread, I'm pondering the very same decision at the moment. I have two acoustics which I bought in my teens (Ibanez Lonestar 500, first guitar I ever bought) and early twenties (Gibson L-00) before I got into metal; what I was playing at the time was mostly acoustic blues and the like. Now I have hardly touched them in years, which is a shame, but they're not exactly designed for anything remotely related to metal.
So I'm thinking of getting me an acoustic whose feel is more similar to my electrics, haven't set my mind on any specific brand this time as long as the neck feels right, the body has a comfortable cutaway and it comes with an integrated pickup. Been trying out several models just these days but haven't checked all shops in town yet. The toughest decision will be which of my present ones to part with - some may say there's no such thing as too many guitars in the house, but it's a question of space as much as of money. I've bought and sold more than half a dozen guitars and basses over the decades, but somehow I feel attached to these two. Damn... (And don't point that Kon Mari book in my face, thank you.)