Eligos
Problem Yet to be Solved
I THINK BLACK DAHLIA MURDER IS A BIG HIT OR MISS BUT THEY STILL PLAY BETTER SHIT THAN 95% OF THE BULLSHIT THAT IS COMING OUT OF THE US TODAY
Most Hit or Miss Bands?
- Thread starter Draehl
- Start date
MasterOLightning
Optimator
In Flames was just a band that had a fair amount of filler on everything from Whoracle onward. At least by Reroute to Remain they tried new things unlike on Clayman where they let about five really samey songs on the album.
I think Dream Theater is pretty balanced on each album. Awake, I&W, and SFAM don't really have any duds in my mind.
Graveland for me, which seems strange because of how little variance there is on each album. But for all the 2000s output, there will be 2-3 songs I really like and the rest will be sort of a snooze. Hard to pinpoint why.
I think Dream Theater is pretty balanced on each album. Awake, I&W, and SFAM don't really have any duds in my mind.
Graveland for me, which seems strange because of how little variance there is on each album. But for all the 2000s output, there will be 2-3 songs I really like and the rest will be sort of a snooze. Hard to pinpoint why.
Eligos
Problem Yet to be Solved
V.V.V.V.V.
Houses Ov Mercury
There are Graveland songs I definitely like more on his newer work...Creator & Destroyer, Dance of Axes and Swords, Fire Dragon of Black Sun...the epic, experimental sounding final track on the new one, etc.
AchrisK
Weakling
Eligos
Problem Yet to be Solved
In your opinion sir
Oh, IntoPhagist. This is why no one takes you seriously. The shit you say reminds me of high school. No shit, it's his opinion.
Xorv
Drug the Priest
this is why intophagist hates this place, whenever he makes a statement/post someone is always there to bash him for whatever reason. Randy moss has more tolerance for this only because I have reason to believe he is too retarded to realize we're making fun of him.
Dak
mentat
I would agree that overall, any band with a large discography has a lot of hit and miss.
Iron Maiden, DT, and In Flames all being great examples.
Iron Maiden, DT, and In Flames all being great examples.
Krow
Garbage Connoisseur
In RM's case...
It's almost unsatisfying...
and
In Flames is 100% miss.
Motorhead.
Bastards - crap
Inferno - win
Ace of Spades - spotty
March or Die - spotty
Bomber - win
Overnight Sensation - crap
That's the extent of my Motorhead collection, but I imagine it goes on like that.
There, I said it.
Bastards - crap
Inferno - win
Ace of Spades - spotty
March or Die - spotty
Bomber - win
Overnight Sensation - crap
That's the extent of my Motorhead collection, but I imagine it goes on like that.
Black Sabbath.
There, I said it.
.
Belligerent
Greekus Urungus
.
Dark Tranquillity, i like The Gallery, Character and Fiction quite a bit but they have made a few albums i could do without.
Moonspell, Night Eternal kicks ass along with the album before it but i'm not sold on their earlier material at all.
im sure there are a shitload more but i can't think right now
SweptbackFlame
twitch.tv/SweptbackFlame
Nah...maybe the later albums...anything Dickinson fucking rules...anything without him just doesn't appeal to me.
I'm going with Judas Priest...
Pyro Stick
Member
Vinterriket. I think Dimmu Borgir can be a bit mit and miss at times as well. I also agree with Dark Tranquillity and In Flames. Soundtrack To Your Escape is some of the worst metal i have ever heard.
IntoPhagist
FloriiiiiiiooooooOOO!
In Flames
Lunar Strain - Good
TJR - Good
Whor - Good
Col - Good
Clay - Good
R2R - Not bad
Sound - Horrible
Come - better than Soundtrack
ASOP - boring
Dark Tranquillity -
Skydancer - Good
Gallery - Good
Minds I - Good
Projector - poop
Haven - Good
DD - Good
Char - Decent
Fiction - good
DT are mad consistent, IF lost it in 2002 some say 99.
SweptbackFlame
twitch.tv/SweptbackFlame
I wouldn't say it's that boring, sure it's wayyyyyy too mainstream, but...there are some pretty catchy tunes on that album.
skeptik
Member
- Feb 7, 2003
- 24,413
- 71
- 48
The Crown is definitely one of those bands for me. Their first demo I love, then their second demo and first album I find to be a bit subpar unless I'm really in the mood for the at times saccharine melodicism that can be found on there. Then Eternal Death is just superb. After the name change, they became good for at least a dud or three per album.
Manowar would be another one.
Manowar would be another one.
Einherjar86
Active Member
metal_wrath
I dip my forefinger...
Agalloch - Some great songs and then some boring songs and instrumentals.
Satyricon - More miss than hit from what I've heard of them.
Soilwork - Some awesome early stuff but they have gotten worse and worse to unlistenable with their later material.
In Flames - first three or four albums are good, the rest is uneccessary.
Paradise Lost, Anathema, My Dying Bride, Katatonia - around every other song from these bands I don't care for. Great bands though.
Satyricon - More miss than hit from what I've heard of them.
Soilwork - Some awesome early stuff but they have gotten worse and worse to unlistenable with their later material.
In Flames - first three or four albums are good, the rest is uneccessary.
Paradise Lost, Anathema, My Dying Bride, Katatonia - around every other song from these bands I don't care for. Great bands though.
Similar threads
