The elite: P. Manning, Rodgers, Brady, Brees
Franchise: Luck, Wilson, Foles, Rivers, Newton, Romo, Rothelisberger, Ryan
Other inconsistent QBs who have more upside than Dalton: Flacco, Stafford, Cutler, E. Manning, Tannehill, Kapernick, RG3
Game managers I would take over Dalton: Palmer, Alex Smith
That's 21 QBs I would rather have.
He had a better QBR this year than Manning, Roethlisberger, RG3, Palmer, Smith, Tannehill, etc. Obviously Quarterback Rating isn't everything, and I wouldn't take Dalton over most of those guys if I had a choice, but he's not a bad Quarterback. He's the best option for Cincy now, and I don't know how you can dispute that.
Follow your own advice. Dalton in his 3rd year has done well so far. He had a bad game in the playoffs (just like you know who); it happens.
I'm not arguing that there's a better QB on the roster ATM, but I am arguing that they need to try and upgrade, or at the very least bring in some competition during the offseason. This roster is stacked and they need a QB who can capitalize on that talent. If I'm Lewis and I see a QB I like in this draft I offer my 1st, 2nd and 2015 1st rounder to go get him. Otherwise, maybe try and get Josh McCown or another vet of that ilk to provide Dalton with some competition.
letting the Packer corners get away with rape
You must be high because you just won your super bowl (made the playoffs) and now you think you know where up is. The last thing Lewis is thinking about is a QB. Again, the kid had a bad game in the playoffs, it also happens to the best. He's young, he has the talent and potential to learn and bounce back.
Uhh... it's three bad playoff games now. He's been awful three straight years in the playoffs. It is certainly legit to ask if he can handle the pressure because some players can just never step up in the big moment.
And I really don't see this "talent and potential" you're talking about. I mean do you honestly look at him and believe he can be a top 10, let alone top 5 QB at any point in his career? AT BEST, he has average arm strength/ athleticism and accuracy. However, his decision making is erratic and based on the number 3+ turnover games he's had, he doesn't seem to bounce back well from mistakes. Now what exactly makes this guy so special that the Benegals shouldn't consider upgrading on him?
I'll take 2 and 2.