I didn't find it to be a good cover at all, and it's certainly not a song I would/could dance to... but then again you said 'goth' club so that explains a lot.
It's a fantastic cover! It sounds so awesome and so 'dark' and what I like most about this cover, is that it sounds different than the original -which is even more challenging to do, in my opinion,than just play it note-by-note like the original version.
At any event: This is a perfect song for a goth club, it falls in the same lines for me as some songs by Tiamat or My Dying bride that also work perfectly for a goth club. You probably think a 'goth' club is a typical child/ emo/ hot-topic childish crap that plays Bullet For my Valentine or some crap like that, and maybe that's all you know, but the clubs I've been going out to contain all 'adults' and they are awesome full of great people and awesome music. I'll take dancing to Depeche Mode, The Cure, New Order or Tiamat any day, especially after a long week of work.
Frankly, I'm not surprised you hate this cover, you're not a fan of that style of music, let alone Nevermore or WD from what I've seen on the board, so no wonder you'll hate this cover.
Oh and neal,
I wear a lot of PVC/ leather/ tight shit/above the knee stockings and all that good stuff. You should come with me one day!!
You too brooks!!
It'll be fun I guarantee you!