just look at that sentence. Don't you get it? maybe it's not what you meant and you had an entire context in your head, but you didn't elaborate and i didn't bother to listen to the song it actually was written about.
Would you understand better if i'd say "Jordpuls is crap because it's sung in Swedish"? I'm not nearly as offended by your comment as you probably would have been if somebody said that. I'm not even german and don't have any german friends either.
Yes I understand what you're trying to say. But I still don't get why I cannot think that it is crap. I don't care what the band is trying to say with the song and I don't care about their lyrics at all. The fact remains; I listened to the song (which had okay music - nothing more) and I
HAD to turn it off once I heard the vocals, because the german language sounds like crap to me when sung. Does that make me narrow-minded or silly? Hell no.
Let me give you an example:
There's plenty of people in Sweden that are deep into metal and does not listen to Vintersorg. The main fact behind this is that to them, they think that the Swedish language sounds like utter crap in metal music. Although I most definitly do not agree with them, they are most permitted to have that opinion and I understand why they have that opinion as well. And they are not narrow-minded or silly because they don't like this particular language in music. Get it?
I did forget to say that Rammstein (and the more industrial kind of music) are an exception to this rule. Because in that kind of music, the german language fits the music extremely well - at least according to my ears. It can also fit with pop and synth music. Does it fit soft, acoustic folk music? Hell no - at least not to my ears.
German (to me) is a harsh sounding language and therefore fits harsh and harder sounding music better than it does softer. And once again, all this is according to my ears. But I know that there are plenty that agrees with me. Perhaps these are the scandinavians that you so eloquently generalize?
I should also add that I think the very same about the Finnish language. I think that the Finnish language in most music styles (but especially folk music and folk metal) sounds like utter crap. I don't know why my ears and brain feels like this but perhaps it is also due to the fact that it (along with German) is a way more harsh sounding language than Swedish, Norweigian, Dutch and English?
Jealous because germans happen to have a very rich folk scene competing with scandinavian which might be offending to the scandinavians, i dunno really. I am sorry to generalize again, i have been scorned for doing that by AMG already, but i just can't help but wonder why is it that scandinavians so often dislike german sung music and even ridicule germans for (trying to) sing in old norse (i know that *you* didn't do the latter). It just seems strange to me and as i have encountered this phenomenon quite often i cannot help but wonder. And Agah agreed with you right there, too.
Oh. My. God.
Where to start?
1. I myself am in no way in any kind of "folk scene"
2. If I would be in some sort of Swedish "folk scene" - would I care about the German? Maybe, but more likely - I wouldn't care at all.
3. Is the German "folk scene" actually competing with the Swedish one? Or any other nationality in the "folk scene" for that matter? I highly doubt that folk musicians compete across the borders. I actually think that most people in the scene doesen't care about competing - wheter they like the language in the music or not.
But you've already concluded yourself that you're generalizing A LOT so I wont bother commenting anymore on that. If the actual topic is that you
"just can't help but wonder why is it that scandinavians so often dislike german sung music" then it has nothing to do with being jealous - right? It is something you are curious about and it has nothing to do with jealousy.
And yes, Agah agreed with me and he is Norweigan. So what? I highly doubt that disliking the German language in music is something that the 5 Scandinavian countries have in common. I am pretty damn sure there's a ton of people living right in Germany, Switzerland, Austria, Colombia, Brazil, Japan, America and the goddamn Vatican State that also dislike the German language in music.
I'm sorry if I'm starting to sound like a broken record regarding the topic - but I don't want there to be any more misunderstandings.
Silly and narrow minded, because you didn't elaborate and i could make my own conclusions. Sorry i forgot to add "I didn't mean to offend anyone". It really sounds like you are not able to appreciate some truly great music only because it is sung in german. If this is true then i think it's sad. Like i think it's sad that some people are not able to appreciate Vintersorg albums/tracks sung in swedish.
Now that I've elaborated on this topic - am I still silly and narrow minded? Or was it perhaps
your assumptions and generalizations that were silly and narrow minded?
I truly am sorry if this came across a bit too harsh, but your statement (of me being jealous, narrow minded and silly) was taken out of completely thin air and actually made me quite irritated.