wow...I'm pretty shocked. I thought you'd be a slam dunk at any uni
Zeph, have you thought about applying to schools outside the states?
That would have been the case several years ago, but now it's a ton more competitive and I just don't have enough credentials yet to be a top choice. But we'll see about Michigan.
The other thing is that I didn't bloom into a full-fledged academic until I was already in college. Had I had such aspirations sooner, I would have been more ambitious in high school and applied somewhere more prestigious. UMaine has not been challenging enough for me but I may be stuck here. Luckily I've got a handful of top-notch professors to stick with and it's my own work that people look at, not necessarily where you attend.
Some people told me to apply to the big guns of England, but after the Ivy Leagues wouldn't take me that would probably have been a pie in the sky.
Big difference between grad programs and undergrad.
Languages, my friend. Take them. I have to master Latin, Ancient Greek, French and German to get a PhD. in Ancient History and I'm sure it's a similar case for Classics, and Philosophy too I'm sure.
Depends on your subfield and whether or not the people on your council care about primary or secondary sources (in regards to the time frame you are studying).
An ethicist won't need the languages for obvious reasons, but a person getting a doctorate in medieval studies certainly might. I say might because it really is up to your chairs. One of the grad students I know had to essentially restart his thesis from scratch because he wasn't translating the original Greek texts himself (his original council member thought that it was perfectly acceptable to use highly regarded secondary sources, but then both had a heart attack and drowned.... r.i.p. Hoffman, you mighty Cartesian planeswalker). His replacement council member was having none of that however.
My undergrad major is English. I may have to take a foreign language but I don't see myself translating original Latin texts anytime soon.
Good luck man. I still think you should study overseas personally, if at all possible of course. You seem willing to live what you study which is pretty cool. I highly doubt most American schools would really be as enthralling as a school located in the area you are studying imo.