Which Opeth album rips your heart out?

[Mantraschism]

Just that: which Opeth album rips your fucking heart out, by just sheer emotional intensity?

For me, My Arms, Your Hearse is the only answer. Especially at this point in life. If I listen to this album as I'm going to bed, I WILL cry -- even to things like 'Prologue'. The lyrics, the rage, the longing, the despair... sometimes it's scary how much I identify with this album. Songs like Karma kill me, even parts like, 'The cold season drift over the land/They all huddle in the brown corners/Some would settle for less/The castles were all empty, asleep/Long awaiting their king/Beckoning 'round the bend'. And the scream at the end. I don't know, just a brutally personal album for me. So that's my choice.

Yours?

 

[synergy]

I'd say say Still Life

 

[err]

the track Blackwater Park.
otherwise, MAYH turns me into a fucking demon when i listen to it

finally, it wasn't until recently that i could listen to "Ice" by Camel without crying.

fuck, anything from Camel is loaded with emotion

 

[NFU]

Just that: which Opeth album rips your fucking heart out, by just sheer emotional intensity?

For me, My Arms, Your Hearse is the only answer. Especially at this point in life. If I listen to this album as I'm going to bed, I WILL cry -- even to things like 'Prologue'. The lyrics, the rage, the longing, the despair... sometimes it's scary how much I identify with this album. Songs like Karma kill me, even parts like, 'The cold season drift over the land/They all huddle in the brown corners/Some would settle for less/The castles were all empty, asleep/Long awaiting their king/Beckoning 'round the bend'. And the scream at the end. I don't know, just a brutally personal album for me. So that's my choice.

Yours?

i recommend therapy. all opeth has emotion. but i wouldnt say they have "torn my heart out".

 

[synergy]

SOX WIN!

woooOOOOOooooOOOOOooooHHooooooOOOOO...............:Spam:

 

[synergy]

Prologue doesnt rip my heart out...it actually kind of scares me. I mean that piano comes out of nowhere...I have to turn down the volume just so that I don't piss myself. From now on when prologue comes on, don't cry....instead imagine me pissing myself

 

[symbolic_acts]

god damn bullshit that sox yanks game was.....

anyway rips my heart out..... lol

id say morningrise and still life are very touching tho

+ Mantraschism for the immortal now playing seems that a lot of people dismiss them cause of their look

 

[BurningSky]

Damnation. Sox blow.

 

[Jon Snow]

Damnation. Sox blow.

If the Sox blow, what does that say about the Yankees?

MAYH and Still Life are the most emotional for me.

 

[The Invoking]

Oh, Gunhaver must be a real MANNNNNNNNN. I mean look he likes baseball and he likes the Redsox.... ohhhhh.

I am going to cry now

 

[Mantraschism]

@Gunhaver: Ok... well, I guess you can fuck yourself. =\


@NineFeetUnderground: 'Rip your heart out' - have you heard of exaggeration? Anyway, I didn't mean that it has so strong an impact every time -- but my current personal situation enhances it greatly. Therefore, I cry to it. I repeat, not every time. Crying to music is not abnormal.

@symbolic_acts: Yeah, Immortal were fucking great. They did have a rather funny image (and I love their lyrics =D), but hell, I'm wearing the 'Sons of Northern Darkness' shirt right now, proudly! \m/ The ultimate in grimness... hehehe.

@synergy: Lol, 'Prologue' doesn't usually have any effect on me at all, aside from establishing a serene and rather sad mood. Like I said earlier, it's just a situation I'm in right now that seems to lend so much more emotion to it (even up to the sound of rain).

 

[ViCyniC]

Just that: which Opeth album rips your fucking heart out, by just sheer emotional intensity?

For me, My Arms, Your Hearse is the only answer. Especially at this point in life. If I listen to this album as I'm going to bed, I WILL cry -- even to things like 'Prologue'. The lyrics, the rage, the longing, the despair... sometimes it's scary how much I identify with this album. Songs like Karma kill me, even parts like, 'The cold season drift over the land/They all huddle in the brown corners/Some would settle for less/The castles were all empty, asleep/Long awaiting their king/Beckoning 'round the bend'. And the scream at the end. I don't know, just a brutally personal album for me. So that's my choice.

Yours?

I don't cry to any music regardless of its beauty because I am neither a homosexual or a female.

 

[Mantraschism]

Ok.

...

 

[sands of the seas]

Orchid

 

[Ermz]

You macho guys are so cool. I want to be you.

 

[scorpian007]

Still Life

 

[FUBAR]

Still Life

 

[OpethNZ]

American Sports suck ass.

 

[Longinus]

See what I meant in Luz' thread?

Anyway, it's MAYH, with SL being a short second and partly BWP.

 

[Cendre]

I don't cry to any music regardless of its beauty because I am neither a homosexual or a female.