Dream Theater - Train of Thought
- Thread starter ScottG
- Start date
I think everyone would have a lot less time on their hands if they started bitching about every single negative comment about their favourite bands from other message boardsKnight of the Templar said:
What a bunch of crap! No one with even the slightest ear for music or great musicianship would say that......They are a bunch of idiots, all of them!
One even says about overture from SDoIT: "Granted some of the melodies and parts of it is were `cheesy` they were 1000x better than anything Romeo can do..."
This guy has no clue whatsoever about music! He actually think that Rudess is a better composer than Michael Romeo! I hate it when people are so ignorant of what is truly great and fantastic...
One even says about overture from SDoIT: "Granted some of the melodies and parts of it is were `cheesy` they were 1000x better than anything Romeo can do..."
This guy has no clue whatsoever about music! He actually think that Rudess is a better composer than Michael Romeo! I hate it when people are so ignorant of what is truly great and fantastic...
shredmaster said:
You're totally out of mind saying that The Odyssey is 1000+ better than overture! Scenes From a Memory is an fantastic record, and makes every SymX albums worthless!
You all should handle the critique about SymX on the DT forum, because you all guys is speaking a lot off shit about DT! I mean, we all deserve the SymX critique, cut the critique, just dig the music you like, and not listen to what you mean is shit!
MorphineChild205
Lt. Horatio Caine
Velocity said:
I believe he was talking about the Overture of Six Degrees of Inner Turblulence (the song), not SFAM.
Yngvai X
Dark Emperor
MorphineChild205 said:
Even then, Scenes does not make every SyX album "worthless." I'll take any SyX album over Scenes any day (well, maybe not the first album).
Mr. Shred-ididle
Its Chinese-Tilt ya' head
- Jan 25, 2003
- 1,701
- 6
- 38
- 34
He probably thought of "Overture 1928" when reading "Overture". Well, "The Odyssey" is better than that one as well; "Overture 1928" is a nearly flawless 3 minute instrumental, but "The Odyssey" is a motherfriggin´ epic if there ever way one! The Overture to 6DOIT is just pointless and boring in my opinion (and DT is one of my favourite bands, don´t get me wrong).MorphineChild205 said:
However, I´d prefer most SX album (actually, anyone safe for the first two) to SFAM, as I haven´t gained complete access to that album yet despite having had it for well over a year now.
Cyclopssss
Member
Personally, I could really do without all the Overture - Crap. I mean, make a good intro to an even better song, after 6DOIT, Michael Romeo really went Disney on DT's Asses...stop the noodle-de-doodly-bits and write a damn good friggin' album!
Velocity said:
I meant "Overture" from SDoIT.Try and not do the same mistake next time. Most people clearly see the difference between "Overture" and "Overture 1928" do you? Stop speaking crap about something if you are wrong, or at least delete the post right after you posted it and found it wrong. Don`t be so hasty...You are wrong when you`re saying we talk as much "shit" on this board about DT as the DT board talks about Symphony X, we have a lot less of those posts.
By the way, "The Odyssey" IS much better than "Overture 1928" too in my opinion...
Mr. Shred-ididle
Its Chinese-Tilt ya' head
- Jan 25, 2003
- 1,701
- 6
- 38
- 34
C'mon guys, we've been through this DT vs. Symphony X crap a million times, just leave it alone.
I was really surprised when a thread about the new DT album turned into the good ol' "who's better" discusion. :roll eyes:
I was really surprised when a thread about the new DT album turned into the good ol' "who's better" discusion. :roll eyes:
shredmaster said:
OMG, how can a person be so mad because of one mistake. What is wrong, have I hurt your feelings or something?! It was mindshocking reading you post, and i did'nt know if i've was gonna cry or laugh!
Mr. Shred-ididle
Its Chinese-Tilt ya' head
- Jan 25, 2003
- 1,701
- 6
- 38
- 34
Knight of the Templar
PEAC EOUT!!
BTW, somwhere on DT are guys offering the album version of "as I am"... has any of you guys, proved that is real?
Yeah, it`s real enough, we have it on the Norwegian DT forum too! @Velocity, sorry if i sounded angry man, wasn`t my intention to make you cry
@Shredididle i`ll try to be more careful, it wasn`t my intention to bash DT and hail Symphony X (although my post contained that too regrettably, force of habit i guess )I only tried to correct Velocity, again sorry if i sounded angry at all, i didn`t mean to make anyone feel hurt. :Spin:
@Shredididle i`ll try to be more careful, it wasn`t my intention to bash DT and hail Symphony X (although my post contained that too regrettably, force of habit i guess
)I only tried to correct Velocity, again sorry if i sounded angry at all, i didn`t mean to make anyone feel hurt. :Spin:Knight of the Templar said:
www.dreamtheater.net
It's legit, but it's playing at 96kbps which bites!
shredmaster said:Yeah, it`s real enough, we have it on the Norwegian DT forum too! @Velocity, sorry if i sounded angry man, wasn`t my intention to make you cry
@Shredididle i`ll try to be more careful, it wasn`t my intention to bash DT and hail Symphony X (although my post contained that too regrettably, force of habit i guess
You sounded very angry, but it's ok my friend! No more DT vs. Symx jabbling (is that a word?).
MorphineChild205
Lt. Horatio Caine
The thing I don't understand about Symphony X/DT comparisons is that the two sound NOTHING alike.
Yngvai X
Dark Emperor
MorphineChild205 said:
The reason people try to compare them is because next to DT, SyX is arguably the most popular band that falls under the "progmetal" label (even tho DT is more prog than metal and SyX is more metal than prog).
