Larf03 said:Clayman wasn't that great either...
OfficerNice said:Are you kidding? *scratching head*
Clayman was awesome.
The songs translated incredibly well into the live setting as well.
*shaking head*
When anyone says 'Mr. Nice' ....I think of Megadeth's cover ofLarf03 said:Well Mr Nice...
Okee dokee.I don't know .. I will agree that the songs were great live but I don't like Clayman... I can't really explain why... I just don't like it that is all.
They were the same album? You mean, with 3 different titles?I think that what got me tired of In flames is their tendency to recycle riffs and sound fuckin' redundant... I still think that Jester Race, Colony and Whoracle were good albums but they were the same album ...
<sarcasm> You mention your need variety, yet you are an Iced Earth and Annihilator fan? </sarcasm>I need more variety... wich is something I get with bands like Testament, Annihilator, Helloween...
OfficerNice said:<sarcasm> You mention your need variety, yet you are an Iced Earth and Annihilator fan? </sarcasm>
Stun said:How can you say Whroacle and Colony are basically the same album? They changed half of their line-up and changed the direction they were heading in. I mean, Whoracle relies on straight-up metal riffs and their trademark melodies start-to-finish... but Colony shows a fair bit of experimentation, with all the clean vocals and catchy chrouses.
I'm not looking forward to the new In Flames... esp. after hearing Watch Them Feed. I hope they start doing more classical and acoustic stuff again... or even more stuff like Metaphor (really cool instruments but I think the singing is a bit much).
You know it and I know it, but nobody's told John Schaffer.Larf03 said:I know that Iced Earth is the last when it comes to originality and variety
The songs all sound the same, except with different members playing.but what are you implying about Annihilator???
Quite a few of them sound the same, actually. I'm not implying they're notThey've got 9 albums out ... soon to be 10 and I don't hear any album sounding the same...
Your statement creates your contradiction. You said In Flames recyclesSome songs are rip-offs of others but I don't think that qualifies as lack of variety considering the extent of Annihilator's catalogue!
So you're saying that Annihilator has more albums out because they'veWHen you speak about in flames... you talk about a band that has 6
full-lenghth albums and about as much of EPs... and those albums have 12 songs tops!
Jesters Race is a fucking death metal (add a dash of melody) classic.Jester Race is just more interresting as it is a bit rawer!
They were written very close to together and recorded in the same studiosColony and Whoracle have the same sound.
That's decent of you.They are not one of my favorite band but I still think they are decent.
WHAT? *Head spinning in circles like the Exorcist*As for my taste in general... I do like some of the bands that are well known for their lack of originality (AC/DC, Iced Earth, Maiden...)
That's fine. I didn't say there was anything wrong. Schaffer steals hisit all comes to taste... I'm a sucker for rockin' AC/DC tunes... I can't help but headbang to Iced Earth fast as fuck gallop riffs... Nor can I help whisling those maiden melodic leads... I like them that'S all... In Flames I don't!
cause all their albums are written by Waters right? Him and SchafferI'd really like to hear why you said annihilator doesn't have variety... I'm curious about that
Right. You didn't push the anger button, (Calling New Exodus Nu-Metal Aggro*Please note that written messaging has the tendency to make someone look pissed when they aren't... I'm just debating my opinion wich is, to me, as good/as bad as yours so my post isn't pejorative*
Hopefully, just exchanging some opinions. I don't need to start a debate*Larf03 gives a beer to OfficerNice because this oughta be a good debate...*
Deadly Embrace said:I tend to agree with Officer Nice's opinions on this thread.......although I respect
Larf03.....for voicing his opinions.........
OfficerNice said:You know it and I know it, but nobody's told John Schaffer.
OfficerNice said:The songs all sound the same, except with different members playing.
OfficerNice said:Quite a few of them sound the same, actually. I'm not implying they're not
any good, just very similar. Waters and Schaffer = egotistical assholes.
Who changes lineups faster? Annihilator or Iced Earth?
The only band that changes lineups faster these days is Vicious Rumors.
You didn't think Alice in Hell and Never, Neverland sounded the same?
Interesting. And I'm starting from ground zero. King of the Kill and Criteria for
a Black Widow sound exactly the same.
OfficerNice said:Your statement creates your contradiction. You said In Flames recycles their riffs and I get the impression you're implying Annihilator doesn't, yet
here you've admitted they do. I could argue you that In Flames songs have
tons of variety since Colony and Whoracle and Clayman and RRTR don't
all sound the same.
OfficerNice said:So you're saying that Annihilator has more albums out because they've
been around longer than In Flames? Yes, I agree. What are you saying?
OfficerNice said:Jesters Race is a fucking death metal (add a dash of melody) classic.
It's perfection handed down by the metal gods.
OfficerNice said:They were written very close to together and recorded in the same studios
and produced by the same guy, with some co-production by the IF guys
so I can definitely see why you'd say they sound the same, so I say that
If my information is correct, I could see why. I love both of those albums.
Colony and Whoracle are awesome albums. They may change little things
on their sound here and there but they've never strayed from the core
of what makes In Flames unique and tr00 and br00tal but there's no way
Whoracle and Colony sound the same. "Insipid 2000" does not sound
the same as "World within the Margin" so I'm blind to understand your
comparison. But I've argued that Annihilator sounds the same. We're
at an 'oranges and apples' kind of discussion.
OfficerNice said:That's decent of you.
OfficerNice said:WHAT? *Head spinning in circles like the Exorcist*
AC/DC with Bon Scott was very, very original. BON OWNS.
Iron Maiden before "No Prayer For the Dying" was very,very original.
We're talking *tttttoooooooooo* many classic, original songs to list here.
OfficerNice said:That's fine. I didn't say there was anything wrong. Schaffer steals his
riffs. So does Waters. They could be galloping, but many bands have
galloping riffs. No argument there. I love old ACDC and IM and IMO there's
no better British Metal than JUDAS PRIEST. HALFORD _IS_ THE METAL GOD.
OfficerNice said:cause all their albums are written by Waters right? Him and Schaffer
have egotistical asshole "I'm a guitar player and a visionary" bollocks
going on. Waters gets new members every 18 months and recycles the
last record and calls it a masterpiece. Uh Yeah.
OfficerNice said:Right. You didn't push the anger button, (Calling New Exodus Nu-Metal Aggro
Wigger music) so there's no rage. I'm chillin like a villain.
OfficerNice said:I'm putting the definition of pejorative in this post since this forum is a gossip
column and most people think I'm full of hot air. Now, there's some
educational benefit. Thanks for the word, dude.
Main Entry: 2pejorative
Function: adjective
Etymology: Late Latin pejoratus, past participle of pejorare to make or become worse, from Latin pejor worse; akin to Sanskrit padyate he falls, Latin ped-, pes foot -- more at [size=-1]FOOT[/size]
: having negative connotations; especially : tending to disparage or belittle : [size=-1]DEPRECIATORY[/size]
- pe·jo·ra·tive·ly adverb
OfficerNice said:Hopefully, just exchanging some opinions. I don't need to start a debate
and have DL come in here and breathe down my back the way she always
does when one of those gets going.
OfficerNice said:*Gives LAR a couple Newcastles*
Cheers.
\m/
yes.Actually... you lost me again... I will agree with you that King of the Kill and Refresh the Demon are similar to some extent but King and Criteria???
Whoa! An Annihilator album being called a masterpiece! You must knowDamn ...King of the Kill sounds like an angry hard rock album compared to the thrash masterpiece that is criteria!
it is? oh. I didnt hear any. I'll take your word for it. seriously.Criteria is much much more speed oriented where King is way more groovy...
Neverland was good, the mix was just waaaaay flat. No meat, no muscle.As for Alison Hell and Never Neverland... I don't see the similarities either... I would compare Alison to Criteria actually... For the speed of both and the line-up too... Neverland is a thrash metal masterpiece and nothing sounds like it in my book... But it MAY be my feelings talking here... I don't know...
Mos Def. (Most Definitely) That was what they were doing. The style,Here is what I feel... Jester Race --- Whoracle ...huge similarities
Whoracle --- Colony ...Still some ...especially in the production
Mos Def.Colony ---- Clayman ...Vocals changed a bit...production
is more interresting
Mos Def. I agree with the mainstream comment about RRTR. BUT,Clayman ---- R2R ... They went mainstream...I think R2R is
Korn trying to do Death metal
Three Ed's?I agree... it's one hell of an album! It's been in my collection since it came out and I have three editions of it
Oh Oh Oh.Wait a minute here... I said that those band were regarded as recyclers... I, for one, have an extended knowledge of these bands so I KNOW that AC/DC with Bon ruled! ANd I know that there are some pretty experimental maiden albums! X-Factor is one hell of an album in my opinion... so is No Prayer but most fans wouldn't agree cuz they are to buzzy going oh oh oh in the trooper!
There a couple along the way, but I dont know which ones you're talkingI prefer Maiden to Judas Priest cuz I think JP has too many fillers on some albums... BUT Screaming, British, Defenders and Painkiller are Untouchable!!!
If he's so down to earth, why does everyone quit all the time. RandyUh... I have met the two individuals and I'd say without hesitation that Schaffer is an egotistical fucker and he is a self-centered cockstar er... rockstar... but Jeff is a very cool and down to earth guy... I don't know how he is as a business man
HA HA. OH OH OH....THE TROOPER.*wears baggy pants and takes a hip pose while listenning to culling the herd*
I'd beg to differ.I like her and I have nothing against her. I was trying...Actually she's great! I'd love to read her take on this matter... I don't have any problem with her and whe's welcome to state her opinion anyday as she's a very intelligent and strong girl... You know why you guys fight so easily? Because you're both intelligent and have strong personalities!
Cheers....MORE beers.Cheers to you too!
AWESOME. EVERYONE SHOULD.When all is said and done... I'm still gonna give a listen to Sountrack to your Escape...
Larf03 said:Gee officer ... that was fun enjoy the Super Bowl!!!
I have a pretty strict shit policy. Three strikes you're out.Larf03 said:Well... the sure like like a new metal band....
Bah I won'T post any opinions till I hear it.... Even if I think R2R sucked I'm still going to give'em a chance.... Clayman wasn't that great either...
HemiGTX said:I have a pretty strict shit policy. Three strikes you're out.
Three in a row...that's bad.