Most Talented Band Ever?

[Gold]

for me talent is how good a band can play, but everyone has different views on what talent is

 

[Belligerent]

Carcass.

No, wait, really. Hear me out.

They created the best:

Goregrind album (Symphonies)
Pure Death Metal album (Necroticism)
Melodic Death Metal (Heartwork)
Post-death metal / death n' roll (Swansong)

Carcass pretty much invented all those genres...and yes Heartwork is one of the best albums ever.

 

[CF87]

Not really.

 

[Hell Awaits Us All]

Carcass pretty much invented all those genres...and yes Heartwork is one of the best albums ever.

possessed invented death metal, napalm death invented grindcore if my memory is correct

 

[ohiogrinder]

possessed invented death metal, napalm death invented grindcore if my memory is correct

no no no...Siege invented grindcore you philistine!

 

[Astrum]

possessed invented death metal, napalm death invented grindcore if my memory is correct

carcass=*goregrind*

 

[Perpetual Catatonia]

carcass=*goregrind*

Yes, but at the time they were playing "grindcore". I think it was later when people started dissecting genres and classified them as goregrind.

 

[Vitor]

no no no...Siege invented grindcore you philistine!

yeah, u r right.

anyway, i know who has a great talent...

Shakira

 

[The Heartbreak Kid]

I hate her voice so much.

 

[Reaping Clarity]

Most Talented:

Melodic Death Metal Band: Insomnium
Doom Metal Band: Daylight Dies
Black Metal Band: Burzum/Summoning (Can't decide between the two)
Hard Rock/Progressive Metal Band: Karnivool

 

[WNxScythe]

Meh. Gorguts.

 

[Thoth-Amon]

listen to emerson, lake and palmer and then tell me PF is "obviously the most talented"



this is entirely an opinion question

Um... if it is entirely an opinion question then how can you say that ELP is more creative and hence more talented than PF...

 

[Hell Awaits Us All]

Um... if it is entirely an opinion question then how can you say that ELP is more creative and hence more talented than PF...

I never implied that, all I was stating is that you can't possibly say that PF is leaps and bounds more talented than all other prog bands (which I what I thought dazed and brutal was implying, but apparently not)

 

[Vitor]

I hate her voice so much.

i don't care about her voice

i'm talking about her... hair.



can you see?

 

[Belligerent]

i don't care about her voice

i'm talking about her... hair.



can you see?

Is there freeze frame on that thing? Sensing there might be a glimpse of mooseknuckle...possibly cameltoe

 

[Carcassian]

possessed invented death metal, napalm death invented grindcore if my memory is correct

LOL@Dave.

Mate, please don't use the phrase "if my memory is correct" if you've been into metal less than a couple of years and learned everything you "know" from Teh Intarweb.

A few of us in here CAN actually remember Napalm Death - Scum from the time it was released, including TV and radio appearances.

In the UK, Steve Wright (useless cunt DJ, now on Radio 2) used to play snippets of ND as a punishment to callers on his radio show if they got his answers wrong.

 

[Carcassian]

Yes, but at the time they were playing "grindcore". I think it was later when people started dissecting genres and classified them as goregrind.

Not really. Symphonies isn't really very much like Grindcore at all, even with the one-foot blasting. Symphonies takes much from trad-thrash riff structures and rearranges them with an atypical for the time death metal oeuvre.

Fuck me, I sound like a cunt/

 

[The Heartbreak Kid]

i don't care about her voice

i'm talking about her... hair.



can you see?

Id still very much fuck her

 

[Vitor]

ok.

 

[Hell Awaits Us All]

LOL@Dave.

Mate, please don't use the phrase "if my memory is correct" if you've been into metal less than a couple of years and learned everything you "know" from Teh Intarweb.

A few of us in here CAN actually remember Napalm Death - Scum from the time it was released, including TV and radio appearances.

In the UK, Steve Wright (useless cunt DJ, now on Radio 2) used to play snippets of ND as a punishment to callers on his radio show if they got his answers wrong.

yea dude we already know that you are a crusty old bastard, thanks for confirming that