King Richard
Hello there
I mean right now... definitely not overall.
Overall, only Manning and Brady are better than Favre.
But the only stretches on there are Eli, Anderson, and Hasselbeck. If Favre played for the Packers still, he would be better than those guys.
I don't judge players' talent off of emotion. For proof of that, I think McNabb is better than every QB but Manning right now... and I hate the Eagles more than anything on this Earth. I just don't see the modern day "greatness" of Favre. He gets credit for the simplest of plays. It gets really annoying hearing the announcer rave about how "no one else but Favre could make that play"... after he threw a screen pass.
He's a decent QB, not bad by any means, but he doesn't belong with Romo, McNabb, and Manning on top of the league.
10 years ago, yeah, he was great... one of the greatest ever, but right now he's just average.
Yeah I totally agree, he isn't on par with his early days. But the reality is, Favre at whatever his age is, is still better than a lot of other QBs right now.