Radiohead Vs Porcupine Tree
- Thread starter Rocky Raccoon
- Start date
i really dont see the relevance in your comparison and i dont see why it is so weird to not like Maynards voice. I just dont really understand how your opinion of '97 Garm has anything to do with his opinion of Maynard.
N-MAYH
New Metal Member
Personally I'd have to go with Porcupine Tree, I mean i have heard radiohead much longer, (my uncle used to play their cds when i was there), but I prefer pt, i like their guitars better and i guess i prefer steve's vocals to the radiohead guys, they do both have awesome songs though, its kinda hard to say (for me)
in_absentia
Aurora Borealis
Lemmy does not approve Radiohead for lack of kicking ass, having fun, drinking booze, fucking groupies, doing meth.
Radiohead sums up the western countries generation pretty well : I feel so sad, life is so hard, I love watching my belly 24/7, I am so insecure, my feelings are creepy.
In fact, I don't see the differences between the feelings expressed in Radiohead's music that the entire Emo/Screamo plague.
Get these guys a fucking beer for Christ Sake !
Radiohead sums up the western countries generation pretty well : I feel so sad, life is so hard, I love watching my belly 24/7, I am so insecure, my feelings are creepy.
In fact, I don't see the differences between the feelings expressed in Radiohead's music that the entire Emo/Screamo plague.
Get these guys a fucking beer for Christ Sake !
It s a fantasy of mine to have Lemmy explain life to Thom 'I doesn't have any veins to slit' York in a confined room where Whiney Boy couldn't be able to escape.
The first sentence by Lemmy would be :
" You see son, I got into music to have pussy ..."
Thom : "Yeah but the pain inside is so hard, our future is doomed and I ..."
Lemmy : "STFU and Listen !!!"
The first sentence by Lemmy would be :
" You see son, I got into music to have pussy ..."
Thom : "Yeah but the pain inside is so hard, our future is doomed and I ..."
Lemmy : "STFU and Listen !!!"
hibernal_dream
A Mind Forever Voyaging
Don Corleone
Emre
im sure our dear mr. rock n roll would say those, but im also pretty sure yorke has much more intelligent things to say...which you have failed to hear or understand so far.
so your comment is lame. you're mistaking radiohead for something they are not: emo.
Don Corleone
Emre
affinityband
Member
I actually dont despise maynards vocals. Maybe they would benefit from different vocals. I still really enjoy them though, but whats all this 'adams playing is too simple?' I just dont get that. why should it matter...
Scourge of Malice
Member
Yeah, they really wouldn't be Tool without Adam. I admit I would like to see what they could do if they added a second guitarist though. I think it would be interesting.
all_sins_undone
New Metal Member
- Oct 5, 2005
- 4,934
- 7
- 0
Maynard's a kind of one trick pony. His voice is really well suited to Tool and to a lesser extent APC, but take him out of that area, and his voice just wouldn't be as effective. It's because of that, that I don't rate him as a singer/vocalist. Sure he's great in Tool, but what else can he really do?
Demilich
Remember
Well for starters, Maynard has been in other bands before Tool and APC (not that I've heard them) but he may have used his voice differently in other bands... wouldn't be the first time it happened 
I think he has a very versatile voice.
I think he has a very versatile voice.
Similar threads
