What is crypto conservatism in this context?
It's no one thing, just a bunch of little things. On the surface, S1 feels like a pretty progressive and iconoclastic season; but a few things never sat right with me, and paired with Pizzolatto's cringey slandering of the fourth season (which, say what you want about it, he didn't come off well), it feels like a quietly conservative story. It's a really smart show, but not always for the reasons it wants to be.
For starters, I never liked the ending of S1. It's too rosy and nice, with Marty's family sitting around him and Rust being all like, "Looks like the light's winning." It's a happy ending that shouldn't be, and it relies on conservative narrative tropes (the world needs bad men to kill the worse men, our women don't understand the struggle we go through but in the end they'll forgive us, good will always triumph over evil, etc.). I can't know how much of this was Pizzolatto and how much was his producers, but given HBO's proclivity for bleak or ambiguous endings elsewhere (
Sopranos being possibly their most successful case in point), I feel as though it's probably his style coming through. And I know this is a tired cliche, but Marty's redemptive arc with his family always feels unearned and too sweet. It's a nice fantasy, but it's just that--a fantasy. Misogynistic, overly possessive dude regains his wife's and daughters' affection not by actually trying with them or working through his problems but by performing some heroic act.
I really like that final episode, but I do not like the last five minutes of it. At least one of them should have died in that fortress, and Marty didn't deserve his family's affection simply because he almost died. The ending yearns too much to reclaim familial wholeness and cosmic justice.