Mort Divine
Shrine Maiden of the In-Crowd
yeah, and that immolation song is in a playlist with bolt thrower, order from chaos, d666, sodom, etc.
so it really is fucked either way
so it really is fucked either way
Themed Mixtape Game
- Thread starter Carpe Mortem
- Start date
Phylactery
Active Member
I do compare and rate songs in relation to other songs in the list and also how well they fit the theme. I have rated things higher in the past for fitting the theme extremely well, like the Alice Cooper track in the non-metal round recently. I can't ignore that Immolation have made music much better than that song, though.
HamburgerBoy
Active Member
- Sep 16, 2007
- 15,042
- 4,723
- 113
Nope. I give points for song quality. I give bonus points for being particularly well-suited to a theme. I take points for being off-theme. I wouldn't give a student points simply for showing up to the right class if all his work was shit.
I don't get any kind of musical apocalyptic vibes from that D666 song, so I can't even say that it feels like it fits the theme. If anything it's a retarded ten minute slog for what should be the most intense and kickass theme in the entire game. Maybe if it was in the middle of the mixtape I would have not reacted as negatively and given it a 1.
EDIT: Actually tbh I didn't even read the lyrics for the song because I found it so musically offensive. Reading them, I don't see anything about the end of the world. Genocide =/= the end of the world. This appears to be a song about a group of people (whether humans or not seems irrelevant) that live for war and killing. A hypothetical song about zombie Hitler conquering the world would not be about the end of the world, it would simply be about wartime victory for the Aryan race at the expense of the rest of it. The world itself is not ending in this song. Off-theme. Zero points.
Last edited:
I don't understand Artillery not fitting the theme.
War - check
Bombs - check
Man-made - check
World Destruction brought about by mankind - check
I don't think the song references a specific individual but rather any armed service member fighting for their country.
HamburgerBoy
Active Member
- Sep 16, 2007
- 15,042
- 4,723
- 113
But it even states that the soldier in question volunteered; it's more of a "You're stupid if you glorify war" kind of song, Disposable Heroes minus the empathy kinda. Soldiers die all the time and it doesn't mean things are any closer to total annihilation.
EDIT: I think the war/bombs stuff is only there to say as opposed to magical or divine destruction of humanity, e.g. no Sodom & Gomorrah (yes I realize that's only two cities) or anything like that. That's also why I don't think the Destroyer 666 song qualifies; if the song is about non-humans, then I'd have to surmise demons or similar which means it doesn't count. If it is about humans on humans, then it's like an anti-Bombfood, glorifying killing and death but never going as far as to say the entire world dies.
EDIT: I think the war/bombs stuff is only there to say as opposed to magical or divine destruction of humanity, e.g. no Sodom & Gomorrah (yes I realize that's only two cities) or anything like that. That's also why I don't think the Destroyer 666 song qualifies; if the song is about non-humans, then I'd have to surmise demons or similar which means it doesn't count. If it is about humans on humans, then it's like an anti-Bombfood, glorifying killing and death but never going as far as to say the entire world dies.
Last edited:
Master_Yoda77
Juggalo
Deströyer 666 - From Genesis to Genocide 10/10
The Krixhjälters - Kill Each Other 0/10
Bolt Thrower - All That Remains 9/10
Carnivore - World Wars III & IV 2/10
Metal Church - Badlands 8/10
Immolation - World Agony 6/10
Polluted Inheritance - Faces 2/10
Terrorizer - After World Obliteration 6/10
Witchaven - Monsanto Death Machine 6/10
Order from Chaos - An Ending in Fire 10/10
Sodom - Burst Command 'til War 9/10
Artillery - Bombfood 3/10
Nuclear Assault - Critical Mass 1/10
Motörhead - Brotherhood of Man 8/10
Just to piss everyone the fuck off.
Oh, and I was super close to submitting either Vitus "War is Our Destiny" or Pagan Altar's "Armageddon" but knew you fags would get all pissy.
The Krixhjälters - Kill Each Other 0/10
Bolt Thrower - All That Remains 9/10
Carnivore - World Wars III & IV 2/10
Metal Church - Badlands 8/10
Immolation - World Agony 6/10
Polluted Inheritance - Faces 2/10
Terrorizer - After World Obliteration 6/10
Witchaven - Monsanto Death Machine 6/10
Order from Chaos - An Ending in Fire 10/10
Sodom - Burst Command 'til War 9/10
Artillery - Bombfood 3/10
Nuclear Assault - Critical Mass 1/10
Motörhead - Brotherhood of Man 8/10
Just to piss everyone the fuck off.
Oh, and I was super close to submitting either Vitus "War is Our Destiny" or Pagan Altar's "Armageddon" but knew you fags would get all pissy.
RedStorm
Death has come
Master_Yoda77
Juggalo
CiG
The Veils of Negative Existence
CiG
The Veils of Negative Existence
Vegard Pompey
ALLY TO GOOD, NIGHTMARE TO YOU
I didn't like this playlist very much. Too much death/thrash which are my least favorite of the major subgenres. My ratings are probably super untrve but whatever.
Deströyer 666 - Genesis to Genocide
I like this album but this song drags a bit. Was gonna give it a 5 but the ending changed my mind.
6/10
The Krixhjälters - Kill Each Other
In light of your complaints I made a sincere attempt at disliking this and at least lowering my rating to a 9 or something. It was a bust.
Second coolest band name ever (corruption of the Swedish word krigshjälte, meaning war-hero)
10/10
Bolt Thrower - All That Remains
4/10
Carnivore - World Wars III & IV
While you guys are getting fed up with this band making it into every round I'm just getting increasingly convinced I need to hear their albums. This is fun as hell and the sound is meaty and great.
7/10
Metal Church - Badlands
8/10
Immolation - World Agony
I don't even like classic Immolation.
5/10
Polluted Inheritance - Faces
3/10
Terrorizer - After World Obliteration
5/10
Witchaven - Monsanto Death Machine
Finally some actual good riffs. Not loving the vocals but it's a decent song.
6/10
Order From Chaos - An Ending in Fire
4/10
Sodom - Burst Command 'til War
7/10
Artillery - Bombfood
It's only really world destruction-themed in the sense that basically any song about war is. I'm not sure that's what Omni intended when she selected this theme, but then I'm not sure it isn't either. I appreciate it bringing some actual melody to this playlist though.
6/10
Nuclear Assault - Critical Mass
6/10
Motörhead - Brotherhood of Man
7/1Ö
Deströyer 666 - Genesis to Genocide
I like this album but this song drags a bit. Was gonna give it a 5 but the ending changed my mind.
6/10
The Krixhjälters - Kill Each Other
In light of your complaints I made a sincere attempt at disliking this and at least lowering my rating to a 9 or something. It was a bust.
Second coolest band name ever (corruption of the Swedish word krigshjälte, meaning war-hero)
10/10
Bolt Thrower - All That Remains
4/10
Carnivore - World Wars III & IV
While you guys are getting fed up with this band making it into every round I'm just getting increasingly convinced I need to hear their albums. This is fun as hell and the sound is meaty and great.
7/10
Metal Church - Badlands
8/10
Immolation - World Agony
I don't even like classic Immolation.
5/10
Polluted Inheritance - Faces
3/10
Terrorizer - After World Obliteration
5/10
Witchaven - Monsanto Death Machine
Finally some actual good riffs. Not loving the vocals but it's a decent song.
6/10
Order From Chaos - An Ending in Fire
4/10
Sodom - Burst Command 'til War
7/10
Artillery - Bombfood
It's only really world destruction-themed in the sense that basically any song about war is. I'm not sure that's what Omni intended when she selected this theme, but then I'm not sure it isn't either. I appreciate it bringing some actual melody to this playlist though.
6/10
Nuclear Assault - Critical Mass
6/10
Motörhead - Brotherhood of Man
7/1Ö
dwellerINTHEdark
Curator of the mausoleum
Deströyer 666 - From Genesis to Genocide
Enjoyable enough blackishness with good riffs. 7/10.
The Krixhjälters - Kill Each Other
Sounds decent and aggressive at times but almost Blink 182ish at other moments. 6/10.
Bolt Thrower - All That Remains
This is awesome. Keeps chugging along but those vox man! 8/10.
Carnivore - World Wars III & IV
Probably my favorite Carnivore song. There's a demo version of it on their other album that I like more which I should've recommended but WHATEVER. 10/10.
Metal Church - Badlands
A fun, rockin' tune. 6/10.
Immolation - World Agony
Pretty dang bland gang. 5/10.
Polluted Inheritance - Faces
Just like the song above but worse. 4/10.
Terrorizer - After World Obliteration
Solid old school aggression. 6/10.
Witchaven - Monsanto Death Machine
Not much to dislike here folks. Loved them vocals. 8/10.
Order from Chaos - An Ending in Fire
I'm getting an Inquisition vibe from the vox which typically ain't a good thing. The rest ok the song is aight. 5/10.
Sodom - Burst Command 'til War
Oh Sodom, you are so great and evil. Lovely pick. 8/10.
Artillery - Bombfood
Man that section in the middle really saves this from being quite very really bad. But yeah it picks up for sure. Good melody throughout though. 6/10.
Nuclear Assault - Critical Mass
It's listenable. So there's that. Sounds very by-the-numbers. 4/10.
Motörhead - Brotherhood of Man
Very cool tune. Laid back but not really. 7/10.
Enjoyable enough blackishness with good riffs. 7/10.
The Krixhjälters - Kill Each Other
Sounds decent and aggressive at times but almost Blink 182ish at other moments. 6/10.
Bolt Thrower - All That Remains
This is awesome. Keeps chugging along but those vox man! 8/10.
Carnivore - World Wars III & IV
Probably my favorite Carnivore song. There's a demo version of it on their other album that I like more which I should've recommended but WHATEVER. 10/10.
Metal Church - Badlands
A fun, rockin' tune. 6/10.
Immolation - World Agony
Pretty dang bland gang. 5/10.
Polluted Inheritance - Faces
Just like the song above but worse. 4/10.
Terrorizer - After World Obliteration
Solid old school aggression. 6/10.
Witchaven - Monsanto Death Machine
Not much to dislike here folks. Loved them vocals. 8/10.
Order from Chaos - An Ending in Fire
I'm getting an Inquisition vibe from the vox which typically ain't a good thing. The rest ok the song is aight. 5/10.
Sodom - Burst Command 'til War
Oh Sodom, you are so great and evil. Lovely pick. 8/10.
Artillery - Bombfood
Man that section in the middle really saves this from being quite very really bad. But yeah it picks up for sure. Good melody throughout though. 6/10.
Nuclear Assault - Critical Mass
It's listenable. So there's that. Sounds very by-the-numbers. 4/10.
Motörhead - Brotherhood of Man
Very cool tune. Laid back but not really. 7/10.
Master_Yoda77
Juggalo
The low ratings for that Order from Chaos song boggles my mind.
no country for old wainds
Active Member
- Nov 23, 2002
- 26,802
- 9,658
- 113
Phylactery
Active Member
I count 12 so far and there were 14 songs in the playlist, so waiting for one other person along with old wainds.
Last edited:
Satanstoenail
My Larpstyle determines my Derpstyle
Satanstoenail
My Larpstyle determines my Derpstyle
Deströyer 666 - From Genesis to Genocide
Pretty meh and way too long 4/10
The Krixhjälters - Kill Each Other
Good bits, shit bits 5/10
Bolt Thrower - All That Remains
Should have been World Eater but still pretty great 8/10
Carnivore - World Wars III & IV
SPLOSION 4/10
Metal Church - Badlands
I never liked this band. This is the song I'm most familiar with of theirs. It's crap. 3/10
Immolation - World Agony
Not bad 7/10
Polluted Inheritance - Faces
Not on theme but I dig the music 6/10
Terrorizer - After World Obliteration
My kind of grind. This album is in my top 3 of the genre. Sandoval is an absolute beast. Raw and controlled at the same time. 10/10
Witchaven - Monsanto Death Machine
Eh 4/10
Order from Chaos - An Ending in Fire
Ok 5.5/10
Sodom - Burst Command 'til War
Pretty shit 4/10
Artillery - Bombfood
Cheesefest 4.5/10
Nuclear Assault - Critical Mass
Liked this a lot. I've only got Survive and this sounds much better. 8/10
Motörhead - Brotherhood of Man
Pretty different for Motörhead. I liked it 7.5/10
I had high hopes for this list but most of it sucked.
Pretty meh and way too long 4/10
The Krixhjälters - Kill Each Other
Good bits, shit bits 5/10
Bolt Thrower - All That Remains
Should have been World Eater but still pretty great 8/10
Carnivore - World Wars III & IV
SPLOSION 4/10
Metal Church - Badlands
I never liked this band. This is the song I'm most familiar with of theirs. It's crap. 3/10
Immolation - World Agony
Not bad 7/10
Polluted Inheritance - Faces
Not on theme but I dig the music 6/10
Terrorizer - After World Obliteration
My kind of grind. This album is in my top 3 of the genre. Sandoval is an absolute beast. Raw and controlled at the same time. 10/10
Witchaven - Monsanto Death Machine
Eh 4/10
Order from Chaos - An Ending in Fire
Ok 5.5/10
Sodom - Burst Command 'til War
Pretty shit 4/10
Artillery - Bombfood
Cheesefest 4.5/10
Nuclear Assault - Critical Mass
Liked this a lot. I've only got Survive and this sounds much better. 8/10
Motörhead - Brotherhood of Man
Pretty different for Motörhead. I liked it 7.5/10
I had high hopes for this list but most of it sucked.
