Themed Mixtape Game

Absu 3
Samhain 2
Slough Feg 2
Primordial 3
Doomsword 3
Eluveitie 10
Morrigan 3
Belenos 3
Heol Telwen 2
Mael Mordha 2
Lost Horizon 3
Pagan Altar 2

there ya go fags
 
  • Like
Reactions: Satanstoenail
Absu - Stone of Destiny
a bit linear and a bit calculated, i tend to like them better when they're more direct. cool tho. 7/10

Samhain - Initium/Samhain
over half the song is a pointless intro. the song itself is the kind of danzig platter i love, more or less. w/e it's just about metal enough. 8/10

The Lord Weird Slough Feg - The Wickerman
there are some killer songs with just about every album (think i gave a 9 to an earlier pick in the mixtape game), but there's always been something a little showy and gimmicky about this band to me (i imagine they work better live). this song leaves me a little ambivalent in the first half but i rather enjoy the extended solo, probably 'cause it's closer to being pure folk rock. 7/10

Primordial - Sons of the Morrigan
it's exhausting when they do this same bombastic thing over a whole album (i'd rather go for something with a bit more restraint and texture like early aeternus), but in small doses it's a lot of fun. helluva vocal performance. 8/10

Doomsword - Death Of Ferdia
vintage epic metal, goes on a bit and i'm not fond of the production. they're that rare band whose last album might actually be their best (along with RESOUND THE HORN anyways). 7/10

Eluveitie - King
get rid of the aggressive chugging and i'd probably not mind this. 3/10

Morrigan - Dance Of The Leprechaun
i specifically messaged kiwi david on FB to tell him there was a morrigan-ready theme going as he's a total fanboy, but his clone beat him to it. they might be the best of all the bathory acolytes. the woman who moderated metal rules/metal archives and kept banning me was called morrigan - metal rules is overrun by spam bots now so i got the last laugh. 9/10

Belenos - Ensorcelé
always hits the spot. super evocative, not in a particularly subtle way but it's just a very satisfying sound. 9/10

Heol Telwen - Enez Glaz
nice twenty minute flute solo. i actually like the sound of this, just not the rushed bouncy songwriting. gimme nokturnal mortum instead thx 6/10

Mael Mórdha - The Doom of the Races of Éire
this is all just blurring together at this point. 6/10

Lost Horizon - Highlander (The One)
i used to like these guys quite a bit but i wish they'd, y'know, tidy up a bit. vocals and some of the leads are really strong. might give it an 8 if it was more on theme. 7/10

Pagan Altar - The Crowman
musicianship and production is still unimpeachable, but too much of a laid back jam for my tastes, and i'm not fond of his vocals in this context (or any context really, but he suited the earlier stuff better). would give a 7 if on theme. 6/10
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vegard Pompey
It appears that @EspaDa picked the right time to start rating again. Slough Feg had the lead until his and Vegard's ratings put Primordial in a tie for first place. Ironically, it was arg's ratings that pushed Primordial to the top. I'm happy to see them win, as it was certainly deserving.

Primordial - Sons of the Morrigan - 7.10 @EspaDa
The Lord Weird Slough Feg - The Wickerman - 6.90 @HamburgerBoy
Absu - Stone of Destiny - 6.85 @Master_Yoda77
Belenos - Ensorcelé - 6.65 @no country for old wainds
Doomsword - Death Of Ferdia - 6.45 @CASSETTEISGOD
Morrigan - Dance Of The Leprechaun - 6.20 @Phylactery
Pagan Altar - The Crowman - 6.15 @Elric of Melniboné
Mael Mórdha - The Doom of the Races of Éire - 5.55 @Krow
Heol Telwen - Enez Glaz - 5.30 @dwellerINTHEdark
Samhain - Initium/Samhain - 5.10 @Talos of Atmora
Lost Horizon - Highlander (The One) - 4.75 @Vegard Pompey
Eluveitie - King - 3.39 @arg

EDIT: It appears that I used "it appears" twice on this page. :heh:
 
Last edited:
oh, I did that actually the other day when I was bored. Was gonna post it when this round ended but I forgot.

First, a recap of the entire game so far:

Round #1: Mountains
Winner: CASSETTEISGOD with Bathory – Enter Your Mountain

Round #2: Extraterrestrials
Winner: Baroque with Voivod – We Are Not Alone

Round #3: Dragons
Winner: Master_Yoda77 with Saint Vitus – Dragon Time

Round #4: Alcohol
Winner: EspaDa with Saint Vitus – Dying Inside

Round #5: Nature
Winner: Vegard Pompey with Scald – Night Sky

Round #6: Ancient History
Winner: Omni with Rainbow – Gates of Babylon

Round #7: Prominent Guest Appearances
Winner: Master_Yoda77 with Griftegard – The Four Horsemen

Round #8: Reincarnation
Winner: Satanstoenail with Slayer – Reborn

Round #9: Mental Illness
Winner: Omni with Judas Priest – Beyond the Realms of Death

Round #10: H.P. Lovecraft
Winner: no country for old wainds with Celtic Frost – Morbid Tales

Round #11: Eponymous
Winner: Omni with Saint Vitus – Saint Vitus

Round #12: World Destruction Brought About By Mankind
Winner: no country for old wainds with Sodom – Burst Command 'til War

Round #13: Cinema
Winner: Satanstoenail with Deicide – Dead By Dawn

Round #14: Corruption and Greed
Winner: Master_Yoda77 with Tygers of Pan Tang – Silver and Gold

Round #15: Love
Winner: arg with Slayer – Necrophiliac

Round #16: Whores and Sluts
Winner: Vegard Pompey with Samson – Vice Versa

Round #17: Ambition
Winner: Satanstoenail with Coroner – Semtex Revolution

Round #18: Dependence
Winner: Funerary_Doom with Johnny Touch – Black Company

Round #19: Literature
Winner: HamburgerBoy with Fates Warning – Giant's Lore

Round #20: Punishment
Winner: Phylactery with The Chasm – Storm of Revelations

Round #21: Gods / Deities
Winner: Elric of Melniboné with Deströyer 666 – I Am the Wargod

Round #22: Michael Moorcock
Winner: Vegard Pompey with At the Gates – City of Screaming Statues

Round #23: Buildings
Winner: Serjeant Grumbles with King Diamond – A Mansion in Darkness

Round #24: Celtic Mythology
Winner: EspaDa with Primordial – Sons of the Morrigan

High score:

Master_Yoda77 – 3
Omni – 3
Satanstoenail – 3
Vegard Pompey – 3
EspaDa – 2
no country for old wainds – 2
arg – 1
Baroque – 1
CASSETTEISGOD – 1
Elric of Melniboné – 1
Funerary_Doom – 1
HamburgerBoy – 1
Phylactery – 1
Serjeant Grumbles – 1

As you can see, Omni is in the lead with 4 wins.
 
Thought I have 3 wins now. Ah, I know, someone stripped me of my victory because I didn't rate.

Also I see Omni had won 3 times, not 4. And she has not been around for like half a year.
 
So I guess I came up with a theme. It's just Metal. Or more precisely, I want songs about metal pride, brotherhood, culture and lifestyle. Also about situations metalheads have to deal with. Don't know if you like this theme but I think it's still better than gore.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HamburgerBoy