Top 5 Drummers of all time

[:Wreath:]

Respect Motherfuckers!

RINGO fucking STARR !!!

 

[:Wreath:]

'Ringo, rofl.'

Fuck, you beat me to it...

 

[a síctia]

no John Bonham? LOL

 

[FRUGiHOYi]

The chick from the White Stripes!

 

[Manbient]

Dave Weckl
Tomas Haake
Virgil Donati
Flo Mournier
Gene Hoglan

something like that. I wish i knew more jazz drummers though, those guys are unreal.

 

[annt]

I know I'll be hanged for this, but in my opinion Ringo Starr, John Bonham and Meg White are way overrated, they are very lacking technically and can't seem to keep the tempo. They would be much less appreciated if they wouldn't have played in such popular groups. Also, I think Bill Bruford's playing is kind of "muddy" or something... well, I prefer Alan White in Yes. And Buddy Rich is sort of a "one-trick pony" with his snare rolls.

 

[:Wreath:]

Get ready for your noose infidel...

 

[Forest of Åsatrú]

Ha ha! What's with al the metal drummers?
5. Billy Cobham
4. Niel Peart
3. Max Weinberg
2. Akira Jimbo
1. Trilok Gurtu

 

[Turbo]

The chick from the White Stripes!

im appauled.

I don't understand your post, but lars ulrich sucks dick heads

I personally thought his/her entire list was unresearched and poorly thought of. Ill remind people that it says "Top 5 Drummers of all time," not "Name 5 Drummers."

1. Daniel Erlandson - Arch Enemy
2. Joey Jordison - Slipknot
3. Jaska Raatikainen - Children of Bodom
4. Adrian Erlandsson - Cradle of Filth
5. (cant think of anymore so...) Nicko Mcbrain - Iron Maiden

End of thread.

 

[FRUGiHOYi]

I know I'll be hanged for this, but in my opinion Ringo Starr, John Bonham and Meg White are way overrated, they are very lacking technically and can't seem to keep the tempo. They would be much less appreciated if they wouldn't have played in such popular groups. Also, I think Bill Bruford's playing is kind of "muddy" or something... well, I prefer Alan White in Yes. And Buddy Rich is sort of a "one-trick pony" with his snare rolls.

 

[Minion520]

In Reverse order:
5. Stanton Moore, Galactic/Corrosion of Conformity
4. Martin Lopez, Opeth
3. Nick Menza, Megadeth
2. Lars Ulrich, Metallica
1. Dave Lombardo, Slayer

Honorable mentions: the dude in System of a Down. Matt Sorum of the cult, G'n'R, Velvet Revolver.

In a Class of their own and cannot be compared:
Igor Cavalera, Sepultura
Neil Peart, Rush

God lord please tell me you're not serious with this list
Peart, yes, lopez maybe, the rest no fucking way especially Ulrich, Cavalera

No particular order
Hoglan - the fuckin man
Weckel - best jazz drummer ever
Portnoy - even though i hate him
Morgenstein - so solid and under rated
Lopez.....maybe, hes awsome but......
Carey - probably number 1
Van Williams - real underrated
Chris Adler - real unique

 

[Minion520]

im appauled.



I personally thought his/her entire list was unresearched and poorly thought of. Ill remind people that it says "Top 5 Drummers of all time," not "Name 5 Drummers."

1. Daniel Erlandson - Arch Enemy
2. Joey Jordison - Slipknot
3. Jaska Raatikainen - Children of Bodom
4. Adrian Erlandsson - Cradle of Filth
5. (cant think of anymore so...) Nicko Mcbrain - Iron Maiden

End of thread.

your selection is not much better

 

[annt]

^my thought exactly

 

[annt]

and Frugihoyi, what the hell are you laughing at? >:|

 

[Turbo]

subsitute Nicko for the Lamb of God drummer.

 

[bondcfh007]

i can't believe any of you stupid bastards hasn't mention Richard Christy yet.

 

[Man In Black]

1. Daniel Erlandson - Arch Enemy
2. Joey Jordison - Slipknot
3. Jaska Raatikainen - Children of Bodom
4. Adrian Erlandsson - Cradle of Filth
5. (cant think of anymore so...) Nicko Mcbrain - Iron Maiden

 

[The Evil Toucan]

Tony Williams
Billy Cobham
Dennis Chambers
Jack DeJohnette
Bill Bruford/Steve Smith

 

[MasterOLightning]

1. Neil Peart
2. Richard Christy (better than Gene)
3. Brann Dailor
4. Trym
5. Portnoy

Honorable mentions to John Longstreth and Sean Reinert.

 

[Jon Snow]

Don't forget Ginger Baker motherfuckers!