Which Anathema is more emotional for you?

[Russell]

The newer or older?

 

[BillowOfZeal]

Without a doubt...the New......i love the old as well, though...when i say new:Eternity..onwards

 

[Nico16]

the new...from Alternative 4 onwards...

 

[D Mullholand]

Most of the old stuff is too clumsy for me... especially the moaning vocals. That detracts from emotionality, I think.

The Silent Enigma and onwards - emotionally superior, if that phrase doesn't sound Norsk Arisk.

 

[Flow]

Please don´t forget "Silent Enigma"! The old neverending pain, combined with the new unbearable easiness to exist.

 

[Melancholia]

Eternity and the silent enigma....

 

[discouraged1]

It depends in what way.

The older is despair, the newer simplified in its melancholia(pardon the pun ).......

I prefer newer, though Silent Enigma (the track) is MY Anathema track........

 

[Garm]

Originally posted by D Mullholand
Most of the old stuff is too clumsy for me... especially the moaning vocals. That detracts from emotionality, I think.

The Silent Enigma and onwards - emotionally superior, if that phrase doesn't sound Norsk Arisk.

What do you mean by norsk (norwegian) arisk?

 

[D Mullholand]

Originally posted by Garm
What do you mean by norsk (norwegian) arisk?

I was questioning the use of word "superior" in my sentence, and this was an attempt at cute burzumhint/wordplay. Oh well.

 

[Joost]

Eternity is maybe the most emotional metal album I ever heard...

'nuff said...

 

[batmura]

The Silent Enigma and onwards.

NP: Lefay - The Seventh Seal

~Mezarkabul

 

[Garm]

The most emotional is definatly on the silent enigma record, from the song silent enigma and onwards.

 

[LoboUivante]

mmm Crestfallen kicks major ass... so does Dying Wish... so does Regret... so does One Last Goodbye... so the asnwer is obvious... i dont know...

 

[Angels_Molestor]

Defenately the new Anathema.........especially from the time they start to show that they are influenced by Pink Floyd

 

[lumen]

I like it all really, but Serenades hits me hardest.

 

[Ivo]

eternity & onwards! But the last one (a fine day to exit) is a bit dissapointing...

 

[Lord S]

Originally posted by llamaura
I like it all really, but Serenades hits me hardest.

exactly!
songs like Lovelorn Rhapsody and Under A Veil of Black Lace are filled with emotion.
Moaning vocals???????/sorry i dont hear that.........

 

[LoboUivante]

Originally posted by Lord S
exactly!
songs like Lovelorn Rhapsody and Under A Veil of Black Lace are filled with emotion.
Moaning vocals???????/sorry i dont hear that.........

first, the lyrics are a little bit superior... with bigger words. The phylosopy is still Anathema but the sound... im letting myself loose on songs as "... and i lust" or "crestfallen"... Vince's moans (it sounds like him) and Darren gutteral growls fit perfectly, in a original way... what can i say? maybe despair...

 

[LuminousAether]

Eternty is by far their most emotional album. They are still more emotional now than they were before Eternity though, except for the song A Dying Wish.

 

[GreyMan]

No one in particular... Averithing is special, from the early Serenades/Crestfallen doom/death to the elettro/rock of A fine Day...
But nothing can surpass Alternative 4