^
A fireball is badass enough, our other guitar player plays one. Perhaps you remember that I have the Powerball, so I can make a direct comparison.
The fireball is loud enough if your band plays at a reasonable volume (what you owe your ears btw). In clubs, at shows etc. your cab will be miced (in most cases) so you won't need a 100W amp.
So the volume is not an important factor here, the headroom maybe. The Powerball has more headroom and therefore sounds a bit better to my ears. Other people say that a tube amp must be cranked to it's end to sound good, these people should go with the Fireball. But keep in mind that modern amps are not really constructed to be cranked up all the way.
The powerball is very flexible and the clean sound is wonderful for a "metal amp". The clean sound of the FB is good too, but it's not as clear as the PB one, my feeling says. The FB is not flexible at all compared to the Powerball. Perhaps you say that you don't need it, but it's better to have it and don't need it than to...bla
The Peavy is a one trick pony imo, but it does it pretty good. The distortion of the Peavy is very different from the PB distortion, you HAVE to test the amps. It might be easier to get a cutting sound on the Peavy, the PB sounds more warm and round to my ears.
You won't get away without testing.
^I would add, the fireball seems more 'raw'. I mean, whereas the powerball has tons of stages and filters and whatnot, the fireball has a more traditional approach. If you want raw distortion, you should give it a try. And don't let the 50W figure deceive you - our ears do perceive volume in a linear manner. It's almost as loud as 100W.
In what twisted universe does 'douche' constitute an insult?
Your tone is bollocks. When you grow up, you'll realise it's the truth.
Thanks both! And yes Corny, I do remember that you own a PB, and actually when I posted I was looking for an answer from you about it, so yeah, thanks
So all in all,
Powerball = Most flexible sound, not as raw distortion, better cleans and more settings.
Fireball = Ass kicking raw distortion, not as good cleans, not as flexible, doesn't matter that it's 50 W.
Peavey 6505 = Either you hate it or love it, strongest/most aggressive distortion.
More or less that'd be it? I do play sometimes directly from the amp, but it's always in really small pubs so I won't need to crank the thing up that much so I think that power won't be the problem here. My dream would be the Powerball, cos versatility is never a bad thing, it's a baddass amp and it's my favourite looking wise, which is the least important thing when choosing a head but still I'm happier if besides sounding as I want, I like it, but it's damn expensive so I may end up going with the Fireball, cos I looked at the Screamer but looks like too many things for such a small head and being cheaper than the FB. I think the Peavey will be my last option cos it's IMO a bit too aggressive sometimes and the distortion is not really versatile.
Oh, and trying is out of question cos there's no store neither in my town or in the not-too-far-away ones that has stock of them, they just have a couple of Bugueras and maybe one really expensive amp, but there's no way I can try them. I've heard live the Powerball more than once from a friend of mine and I like it, and I played once a 6505, Fireball is the only thing I've not tried, but if you say it's really nothing to worry about those 50W then great.