Of Sins and Shadows: 8.5
Sea of Lies: 8.5
Out of the Ashes: 7.5
The Accolade: 10
Pharaoh: 8.5
The Eyes of Medusa: 7.5
The Witching Hour: 7
The Divine Wings of Tragedy: 10
Candlelight Fantasia: 9.5
Smoke and Mirrors: 8
Church of the machine: 8.5
Sonata: Not sure what to rate this....
In the Dragons Den: 6.5
Through the Looking glass: 9.5
The Relic: 8
Orion the Hunter: 8.5
Lady of the Snow: 8.5
I really think this list is about right. I noticed i rated them all pretty high, but i did that for all of them so its fine.
Someone that disagrees with my list PLEASE tell me why, i want to know why people like Twilight in Olympus so much better then DWoT!!
Redragon
I actually think that your list is pretty much spot on. I maybe gave Pharaoh a little too low points, but I think you over-rated it a little. 7.5 would be better...
Nothing really wrong there though, in my opinion.