Which Reviews on Royal Carnage do you dispute?
- Thread starter Papa Josh
- Start date
JayKeeley
Be still, O wand'rer!
OK man, I've re-read my review and I've got to say that I think I hit the nail on the head. Compared to other Soilwork efforts, FnF is without doubt their worst.
I would love to hear other peoples opinion on the review (provided they've heard FnF obviously). Was I too harsh? Was I wrong to give it that write up and score it with a 4.5/10?
I would love to hear other peoples opinion on the review (provided they've heard FnF obviously). Was I too harsh? Was I wrong to give it that write up and score it with a 4.5/10?
bloodfiredeath
kaiju eiga
I've heard the album, and 4.5 was too generous. Then again, I'm biased in that I FUCKING HATE all Soilwork's shit with a passion. 
Erik
New Metal Member
J.
Old Fart
bloodfiredeath
kaiju eiga
I usually think that people who use being drunk as a reason why they post something are retards. But honestly, I have no recollection of typing what I did above. Not that I don't agree with myself.... 
Heils to Rebel Yell Whiskey.
Heils to Rebel Yell Whiskey.
NAD
What A Horrible Night To Have A Curse
Drunk posts are great.
I saw Soilwork live with Killswitch Engage and Hypocrisy last year, they weren't all that good. The guitar work was kinda cool, but that didn't take away from the fact that they were boring. Hypocrisy owned, of course.
I saw Soilwork live with Killswitch Engage and Hypocrisy last year, they weren't all that good. The guitar work was kinda cool, but that didn't take away from the fact that they were boring. Hypocrisy owned, of course.
neal
wizard in black
The only time I saw Soilwork live they weren't that good.. The sound was awful. But that could be attributed to the lackeys we have running sound in Houston venues.
Erik
New Metal Member
It's the most decent of 'em but why would I want to listen to a second-rate version of "Slaughter of the Soul" when I have the real thing handy?neal said:
JayKeeley
Be still, O wand'rer!
duh - because Slaughter of the Soul came out 3 years before Steelbath Suicide. If you listen to anything more than 5 years old, then you must be living in the past. You might as well be claiming welfare.Erik said:
Me on the other hand, I'm so down with it, I'm listening to the new Stratovarius CD and it 'aint even out yet!
Black Winter Day
Member
JayKeeley
Be still, O wand'rer!
NAD
What A Horrible Night To Have A Curse
That was awesome."Is this chicken or is this fish what I'm eatin? Acuz it say chicken of the sea, but tayste lyke feeesh..."
You fucking dumb bitch, that's what it takes to be a millionaire!?!??
neal
wizard in black
ouch haha. steelbath suicide might be better than sots if the first half was as good as 7-11. soilwork has (had i guess) more energy than the rest of the melodeath 'big boys'.Erik said:
ok i dont get the welfare comment. i listen to albums more than 5 years old haha. not too many that are more than 10 yeas old though...and even less past the 15 year mark haha. oh well. too much new stuff to waste time on things i heard a bazillion times when i was 16.JayKeeley said:
-neal
bloodfiredeath
kaiju eiga
The one I just saw she didn't want buffalo wings because she "doesn't eat buffalo."NAD said:
"Is this chicken or is this fish what I'm eatin? Acuz it say chicken of the sea, but tayste lyke feeesh..."
You fucking dumb bitch, that's what it takes to be a millionaire!?!??
Amazing!
JayKeeley
Be still, O wand'rer!
Oh sorry, maybe 'social security' checks? Whatever handouts you get in the US when you become old and decrepid....the timing's all off for the joke now, heh.neal said:
NAD
What A Horrible Night To Have A Curse
Ayeka
Hell Bent For Leather!
No it bloody well isn'tmarkgugs said:Well that's just daft.
well, maybe it is now that Dance of Death is out 
