Being a guitarist, I have to say this album isn't their best. But you know what? It's still Children of Bodom--it's still the great music but a little (okay maybe a lot) different. I listen to this album when I am working out and stuff but I hardly ever listen to it on my real free time, because as a guitarist I want to learn songs that will actually help me improve my skills and Are You Dead Yet? doesn't help me a whole lot. Plus, I just love the sound of the other albums, with exception to Something Wild.
I think this comes because I started listening to Children of Bodom not too long ago, I was looking for something great to play and this was it. I bought Follow the Reaper, not knowing how good it would be, and I almost dropped a load in my pants. So, not too long after that I go and buy Are You Dead Yet? I thought it would be the same and I was glad it was different. I'd hate to say it, but a lot of the songs on Follow the Reaper are a lot alike, it would suck if they just kept with that style (like Dragonforce).
The album really got me liking Children of Bodom, so I bought more. Although I laughed at the album for the silly guitar, I kept listening to it more and more, and it has kind of grown on me. When I went and saw them, I wasn't really paying attention to the song they played, because I was just like "shit it's bodom! fuck they rule!" They were really great on all of their songs (this was when I only had Follow the Reaper and Are You Dead Yet? so I didn't know all of what songs they were playing either).
I understand people not liking the album because of the lesser guitar and whatnot, it's just not something you'd blast in your room alone because you'd feel retarded, but it sure as hell gets the party going more than any of their other albums (especially Something Wild). And even though I love this album, I just hope the next album is different, that's what they've done so far and that's what's worked fucking great so far.