MasterOLightning
Optimator
ITNE is definitely better. It's pretty clearly in the top five or so black metal records. I haven't heard of any BM bands using symphonic keys quite so well. Every other attempt at symphonic BM I've heard has been beyond gay. (Albums where keys heavily dominate guitars = fail.) The style is not really a favorite of mine. Yet I think ITNE is near, if not at the absolute peak of black metal.
Anthems sounds as if someone turned every bar on the EQ up all the way. There's no balance at all in the production. It doesn't sound like black metal. The riffs aren't really black metal much of the time. The drums are too busy, and the keys are doing too much as well. I have a hard time disagreeing with the assessment that this is not a black metal album. It's more similar to IX E and Prometheus than ITNE. Anthems might be one of the first albums to fall into the vague "extreme" metal category.
Anthems sounds as if someone turned every bar on the EQ up all the way. There's no balance at all in the production. It doesn't sound like black metal. The riffs aren't really black metal much of the time. The drums are too busy, and the keys are doing too much as well. I have a hard time disagreeing with the assessment that this is not a black metal album. It's more similar to IX E and Prometheus than ITNE. Anthems might be one of the first albums to fall into the vague "extreme" metal category.
Read that as 2nd wave Jewish black metal fucking rules.