I listened to Paracletus again, and I've decided that upon further listen I really do like it, my initial feelings of disappointment have subsided. I think it's much better than Fas. I think it sits somewhere in between the previous two albums in terms of sound.
So here's where I sit with it:
I found Paracletus closer to Kenose than
Fas, but imo, it drags, as did
Fas. There is actually too much going on again, but it isn't as quite dense as the previous album (thankfully). It gets progressive sometimes, even rock-like, which I never thought I would say in relation to DsO.
I don't find the album particularly dark. The production is too organic and warm, especially on Mikko's vocals. The production doesn't sound
bad, it just strips away the extremity. I don't feel uncomfortable or unsettled listening to it, which is something I liked up to Kenose: feeling unable to settle in because it was so extreme and so dark, so blasphemous.
Not a bad album, not by any means, but it is far from stellar. DsO have softened: they still sound great, but they have been far greater.