all_sins_undone
New Metal Member
- Oct 5, 2005
- 4,934
- 7
- 0
Braighs said:err...ok. What's your point?
My point was: If you think BWP is pure genious, you can't say GR is crap.
No, I think his point was that all Opeth albums are similar or related in a way. The reason why he said "apart from Damnation" is because it doesn't sound like the others, it's a different experienceStormwatch said:My point was pretty obvious. You say (paraphrasing you here): "Non can say they hate an Opeth album, apart from Damnation".
So how come Damnation is so bad? You not like that one then? See, your argument kinda collapses there eh?
in limbow said:Of course I have opinions, I'm just saying that the manner in which the threadstarter stated his was kind of rude, and this thread is not necessary- as I said there's already been countless ones like this.
in limbow said:No, I think his point was that all Opeth albums are similar or related in a way. The reason why he said "apart from Damnation" is because it doesn't sound like the others, it's a different experience
I'm not saying I prefer to see a million threads about how great GR is, I just think this thread is unnecessary... maybe it does promote discussion or whatever but mostly just a lot of people flaming the threadstarter and a few agreeing... nothing new. There are a million threads like this one.Stormwatch said:You'd prefer to see another hundred threads saying how cool GR is then? Come on, message boards are supposed to promote discussion - if everyone agrees there is no discussion, only sycophancy.
This guy's post stands out.
As for there being countless posts like this - sorry, I don't check in here all that often, his was the only one I saw.
Stormwatch said:What's that got to do with anything? He was suggesting no one could have a bad opinion of Opeth albums because they're all great (oh apart from Damnation). He's basically made a post ostensibly disagreeing with a point, yet inadvertently made the exact same point himself: Opinions, that's all it's about. Opinion.
Braighs said:arghh. No. Let me put it this way. If you like Still Life, you will most likely like Blackwater Park and Ghost Reveries. Now...if you like Damnation, you might not like Deliverance or any other Opeth album. ie, you might not be into metal at all.
in limbow said:I'm not saying I prefer to see a million threads about how great GR is, I just think this thread is unnecessary... maybe it does promote discussion or whatever but mostly just a lot of people flaming the threadstarter and a few agreeing... nothing new. There are a million threads like this one.
Stormwatch said:Okay, fine. I like Still Life, but I don't "mostly like" BWP. I mostly like Deliverance. I think GR is the weakest of them all apart from Damnation.
i.e.......It's all about opinions and voicing them..
Braighs said:stop f'ing twisting my words. I used SL and BWP as mere examples.
Would you say harsh words about GR?
edit - I agree about voicing opinions - It's great. Do it! The first post just sounded harsh to me.
Forest of Åsatrú said:lol fine then. Travel the vast lands and see the Forums of Lame.
Stormwatch said:What? :zombie:
Braighs said:he's from that other Opeth forum...don't pay any atention to him.
Mikael Åkerfeldt said:Well I pretty much check this forum as often as I can and it's highly entertaining most of the time. The slagging biz is something I'm very used to as well and I too slag bands and people off ALL the time. As time pass I will not be affected by negative comments about this album. But right now, "Ghost reveries" is quite new to me, I'm proud over it, and a bit more sensitive about it, is all.
Cheers
Mike
Mikael Åkerfeldt said:And "Isolation years"...man, that's on of my personal fave opeth song ever and I was literally in tears singing it. I feel gutted that somebody can take the piss out of GR so completely that I actually feel the need to respond and I feel angry. Plain and simple, your opinion is noted but by no means will I contemplate what you said because you're there and I am here, simple as that...
Best regards
Mike