Themed Mixtape Game

i doubt even mort likes that shite.

i think the general consensus is that while it had precursors here and there beforehand, 'indie' really kicked off in the '80s with bands like the pixies, sonic youth, dinosaur jr. etc. it's been applied to all kinds of movements since then though (inc. the one you mention), and become more and more divorced from the independent/DIY sensibility it originally stood for. these days it's kind of a vague catch-all genre tag for anything vaguely alternative+hipster-friendly.

Well that Polyrock example reminds of that stuff, just an earlier version and less bad. It has those fucking annoying vocals and the bouncy rhythms that I hate. Now you've clarified this I can't just write off the entire genre, though.
 
I haven't heard the Summoning album Let Mortal Heroes Sing Your Fame but I remember reading that some of the lyrics for that album were inspired by Michael Moorcock too.
 
i doubt even mort likes that shite.

i think the general consensus is that while it had precursors here and there beforehand, 'indie' really kicked off in the '80s with bands like the pixies, sonic youth, dinosaur jr. etc. it's been applied to all kinds of movements since then though (inc. the one you mention), and become more and more divorced from the independent/DIY sensibility it originally stood for. these days it's kind of a vague catch-all genre tag for anything vaguely alternative+hipster-friendly.

To be honest, the only bands I've come close to liking from that movement has been Sonic Youth and the Pixies. Other than that, nothing. Honestly, its creation isn't really anything I particularly care for. I mean, it spawned Nirvana for goodness' sake. One of the most overrated bands on the planet when compared to their contemporaries. It's ridiculous. Alice in Chains, The Melvins, Soundgarden, Faith No More and Type O Negative were making better albums during the 90's anyway and they are only some of the bigger names.

Also, I never got the saying that grunge "killed" metal. Seriously? A lot of my favorite bands and albums originated (or got bigger) in the '90's (Edge of Sanity, Opeth, Death, Solstice, Darkthrone, Solitude Aeturnus, Blind Guardian, Dark Moor, Iced Earth, Dark Tranquillity, etc.). Just because a genre goes underground and has a renaissance of its own with the invention of new forms and styles doesn't mean it's "dead".
 
Last edited:
Polyrock rules you wankers.l submitted that and from memory only had a few negative reactions. And it was released in 1980! years before indie gods Pixies, Dinosaur Jr and Sonic Youth. For whoever heard them then they were an influence and rightly so
 
I bought a few albums by them a couple of years ago. They're decent enough but maybe I don't quite get their music sometimes because most of their fans praise them above almost any other band.
 
Well that Polyrock example reminds of that stuff, just an earlier version and less bad. It has those fucking annoying vocals and the bouncy rhythms that I hate. Now you've clarified this I can't just write off the entire genre, though.

the polyrock thing wasn't my cup of tea either but it seemed pretty good for what it was IIRC

To be honest, the only bands I've come close to liking from that movement has been Sonic Youth and the Pixies. Other than that, nothing. Honestly, its creation isn't really anything I particularly care for.

i think it's been responsible for shitloads of great music but, as with most genres, you have to dig under the mainstream surface to find most of it. the nirvana argument isn't really a good one: i mean, heavy metal spawned trivium.
 
Mekong Delta - Heroes Grief 6.5/10
Nice intro to the playlist. Not one of the better Mekong Delta songs that I've heard. Still, it's decent.

Skelator - Elric the Dragon Prince 7.5/10

Yeah, this is pretty good. Really like the vocals especially, but I feel that it tries to be more epic than it ends up being. I'm going to check out the full album after this I think.

Crypt of Kerberos - Stormbringer 7.5/10

Cult band, awesome pick. From what I remember, the compilation albums contain their best material but I haven't listened to these guys in ages. Disappointing ratings for it so far!

Wolfbane - Elric of Melniboné 7/10

I liked this more on second listen, probably 'cos I really enjoy this sort of production a lot. It is a bit repetitive yet manages to be entertaining throughout.

Stormbringer - Tales of the White Wolf 8.5/10

Okay this is fucking awesome and the best song so far. Raging and energetic heavy metal rhythms throughout. Love the intro and verse riffs especially.

At the Gates - City of Screaming Statues 10/10

Obviously the best thing on the list. Full of weird and disturbing riffs and seemingly jarring transitions that all make sense on repeated listens. That part starting around 4 minutes, christ, it's so fucking dizzying. More death metal should attempt to be this intelligent.

Diamond Head - Borrowed Time 7.5/10

I'd probably rate this a point or so higher if it was shorter because I do enjoy pretty much everything about it

Sacramentum - Overlord 7/10

But Pompey, this is bad Sacramentum compared to FaFtS. It's not bad, it's just nowhere near as emotive or as melodically interesting as the aforementioned album. It does have a nice atmosphere to it and some decent riffing. I'm going to relisten to later Sacramentum and try to judge it without FaFtS in mind.

Domine - The Freedom Flight 7.5/10

Lol, the chorus is definitely quite bad and rather overblown. The rest of it kicks arse. Wish I could rate this higher.

Apollo Ra - Bane of the Black Sword 9/10
This is fucking amazing and a great closer for the list. Love the wailing vocals. Never even heard of them so thanks whoever submitted it!

I'd never heard nearly half of this playlist so it was a good one for me. Nothing that was completely awful for once either.
 
Apollo Ra - Bane of the Black Sword 9/10
This is fucking amazing and a great closer for the list. Love the wailing vocals. Never even heard of them so thanks whoever submitted it!

I'd never heard nearly half of this playlist so it was a good one for me. Nothing that was completely awful for once either.

You're welcome. ;)
 
Last edited:
You're not supposed to reveal what you picked until the end! Also, why the fuck does it say Slayed Necros when you quoted my message?!

Sorry, I did it last time and it didn't exactly affect the results. Won't happen again. As for why it says his username...I have no idea. I could have sworn I quoted your message.
 
Mekong Delta - Heroes Grief – 10/10

Definitely one of my favorite Mekong Delta songs. I love the atmosphere behind this, super distorted and ugly bass starting things, then that angular Sabbathy riff and dismal wailing chorus, and as far as I’m concerned the gradual build up in the second half with the eerie 6/4 march and backing keyboards beat the Norwegian black metal bands to the punch by several years. Pretty much everything on their first three albums takes an unusual and original take on classic metal, but this in particular is one of those songs that does its own thing and doesn’t give a shit.

Skelator - Elric the Dragon Prince – 8/10

I’m such a cheapass because I mostly just listen to their early album they have for free download. This sounds like a completely different band, but still quite good. Great singer, really thick but vintage sounding guitars, thoughtful songwriting, the way retro metal should be.

Crypt of Kerberos – Stormbringer – 5/10

Never got into this album. This song is just kind of dull to me, the riffs go through different moods but are individually too rudimentary to be interesting. Solo was the only good part.

Wolfbane - Elric of Melniboné – 7/10

Never heard of these guys, surprisingly good stuff and kinda a rare style for the NWOBHM. Almost a melodic non-doom Saint Vitus kind of vibe here, pretty bleak and moody.

Stormbringer - Tales of the White Wolf – 8/10

I’ve listened to the Stealer of Souls demo a number of times (and never liked it much) and this doesn’t sound anything like it, at first I thought this was another band and a newer one. Clean, heavy, speedy, pretty simple but damn this has really good energy.

At the Gates - City of Screaming Statues – 9/10

One of the proggiest songs from the album and one of my favorites, full of chill-inducing riffage.

Diamond Head - Borrowed Time – 6/10

Solid song that I’ve always wanted to love. I think the slick production and synths work well here, and no doubt Sean Harris had a perfectly expressive voice for this kind of music, but the arrangement is just too dull. Unrelated and not affecting the rating, but I never noticed before how sloppy the drumming was on this, lol.

Sacramentum – Overlord – 8/10

These guys have more than one album? Cool. Sounds pretty damn solid on first impression actually, real riffs all the way through and the production while immaculate still sounds really dark and heavy. The instrumental passage is really making it for me, bumping it up an extra point on account of that. Liking this much more than anything from the first album.

Domine - The Freedom Flight – 5/10

The more I actually hear of Italian power metal, the more I realize there are far flowerier (AutoCorrect didn’t complain about this? amazing) countries out there. Solid speedy stuff with an admittedly hilarious chorus. Not special enough and too long to get anything more than an average rating though.

Apollo Ra - Bane of the Black Sword – 9/10

Very happy to see these guys here, that intro/chorus melodic riff is just so pleasing and the verses have that crunch and sneer that gives me a big 80s Savatage chubby. One of my favorites on this album, and because I hadn’t even thought about them for the theme I’ll add a bonus point because it’s a really great song anyways.

Great playlist, definitely one of the best.
 
Sacramentum have 2 albums other than FafTS. You actually might like The Coming of Chaos as it's pretty much a melodic death/thrash album from what I remember and it sounds pretty much nothing like FafTS.