What band(s) has/have, IYO, a perfect discography?

[Mort Divine]

The Winterlong isn't even more than a half hour.

 

[The Ozzman]

I don't consider Terminal Spirit Disease long enough to be a full-length.

So what do you consider Reign in Blood?

 

[waif]

It's still a full-length album, even if it's shorter than many other albums. There's shorter albums, too.

There's no definition for full-length, so we can't really debate this.

The Winterlong isn't even more than a half hour.

Neither is TSD, if you don't count the live tracks (and since when do you put live tracks on a studio album? That's something you do with an EP).

 

[Omni]

There's no definition for full-length, so we can't really debate this.

Actually there is a definition.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Album

A full-length is a release that's too long or contains too many tracks to be an EP.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extended_play

Usually, an EP has around 10–20 minutes of music, a single has up to 10 minutes, and an album has 30–80 minutes. Mini-LPs generally contain 20-30 minutes of music. In the United Kingdom, the Official Chart Company defines a cut off between EP and album classification at 25 minutes length or four tracks (plus alternative versions of featured songs).

That release is 35 minutes and contains too many songs to be an EP, which is what it would be if it wasn't an album. Album and full-length are synonyms.

 

[waif]

I don't count the live songs, as they're bonus tracks or whatever, which puts it at under 25, which is the cut-off according to the Official Chart Company.

pwned.

 

[Omni]

First off, there's too many tracks for it to be an EP, even without the live songs.

Second, every issue of it, including the first one, has live versions of "All Life Ends," "The Burning Darkness," and "Kingdom Gone" as part of the track listing, which means every version of it is at least 35 minutes long. Considering that albums aren't always exclusively composed of studio material, that's not even a moot point.

The later reissues add three bonus live songs in addition to the three that were already present on the original release.

It's an album.

 

[waif]

give me an example of a real genuine studio album that has live tracks on it that aren't bonus tracks.

 

[CF87]

Terminal Spirit Disease is 6 song e.p and regardless it was reissued with live tracks it's an e.p because it's not from the same material written and recorded during the time. It's not a fucking fullenth. I don't care if it was 15 minutes or 40.

Reign In Blood is obviously a fullenth. JESUS FUCK

 

[Omni]

give me an example of a real genuine studio album that has live tracks on it that aren't bonus tracks.

Bonus tracks that appear on every single version of an album?

Oh, and lots of artists, including Swans, Neil Young, Diamanda Galás and thousands of others have released albums composed of studio and live material.

Terminal Spirit Disease is 6 song e.p and regardless it was reissued with live tracks it's an e.p because it's not from the same material written and recorded during the time. It's not a fucking fullenth. I don't care if it was 15 minutes or 40.

EPs have a maximum of 4 tracks. There are tons of albums that have material from multiple sessions, sometimes spanning years at a time.

 

[Ender Rises]

None of the above.

And none of the below either.

Can't really have a perfect discography. There's gonna be at least one shitty song.

 

[CF87]

Bonus tracks that appear on every single version of an album?

Oh, and lots of artists, including Swans, Neil Young, Diamanda Galás and thousands of others have released albums composed of studio and live material.



EPs have a maximum of 4 tracks. There are tons of albums that have material from multiple sessions, sometimes spanning years at a time.

I don't care. whatever

Fuck Neil Young!

 

[The Ozzman]

I don't care. whatever

Fuck Neil Young!

FUCK YOU FAGGOT!

Neil Young is awesome

 

[Einherjar86]

I don't care. whatever

Fuck Neil Young!

Fuck you back.

 

[CF87]

Fuck you!

 

[Omni]

FUCK YOU FAGGOT!

Neil Young is awesome

.

 

[CF87]

(i'm outnumbered someone help)

 

[Life Sucks]

Neil Young is not my cup of tea, but I wouldn't say he sucks. I'd rather listen to Edge of Sanity.

 

[Einherjar86]

(i'm outnumbered someone help)

Why would anyone help you defend that statement? It's absurd.

 

[waif]

Terminal Spirit Disease is 6 song e.p and regardless it was reissued with live tracks it's an e.p because it's not from the same material written and recorded during the time. It's not a fucking fullenth. I don't care if it was 15 minutes or 40.

Reign In Blood is obviously a fullenth. JESUS FUCK

This is my opinion.

Bonus tracks that appear on every single version of an album?

Oh, and lots of artists, including Swans, Neil Young, Diamanda Galás and thousands of others have released albums composed of studio and live material.

EPs have a maximum of 4 tracks. There are tons of albums that have material from multiple sessions, sometimes spanning years at a time.

Yes, but this material was obviously created by faggots.

(i'm outnumbered someone help)

Why would anyone help you defend that statement? It's absurd.

Then this is a job for...SouthernTrendkill!

 

[Omni]

Yes, but this material was obviously created by faggots.

Swans, in particular, were very influential on music that you apparently like if the graphic in your signature is correct. They were also probably the most brutal and crushingly loud live band ever.