To many people it seems, nearly every Swedish black or black/death album sounds like Dissection.
Black Metal.
- Thread starter ROBL2500
- Start date
To many people it seems, nearly every Swedish black or black/death album sounds like Dissection.
Der Morgenstern
Trailer Park Bacchus
They're a pretty handy point of reference for lazy comparisons. It's like how people compare any of the new 'osdm' bands to Entombed.
It goes beyond that though. I don't have a problem with people making comparisons to Dissection or saying "if you like Dissection, check this band out" but far too often too many bands get written off as Dissection worship when that isn't the case at all.
Lazy comparisons by lazy listeners who probably download too much music and only listen to anything once before forming an opinion.
Blind Guardian
Member
From Sworn to the Dark and on it really does sound like Dissection though, perhaps with some Mayhem on the side.
JontRevolting
FALSE ARREST! FALSE ARREST!
I think from memory even the review of Rabid Deaths Curse years ago gave a comparison to Dissection and I guess that's why I did'nt checkout Watain.I like Dissecion's 'The Past Is Alive(The Early Mischief) compilation and 'Thorns Of Crimson Death' off SOTLB but find alot of their stuff pretty uninspiring.
Draehl
Lurker
Moonsorrow- Just started listening to these guys a couple days ago. Good shit I must say. Solid elements of black metal, folk, and a touch of symphonic without going overboard. I don't see why this band gets the crap it does. Verisakeet is great (especially Pimea), moving on to another album next, suggestions?
Thralldom
Winter of My Bliss
Runk said:
Yeah, I know. I'm sure that Watain's tour with the reformed Dissection had an impact on them. People kept making the comparison when that album came out.
I really think that The Somberlain is by far the best from Dissection, probably because of John Zwetsloot. Although they are influential, I don't think that Dissection is a very good reference point to compare most other Swedish black metal bands with, although Dawn, Unanimated and Sacramentum all share qualities with them.
skeptik
Member
- Feb 7, 2003
- 24,413
- 71
- 48
What I've heard from Lawless Darkness sounded much more compelling to me than what I've heard from Sworn to the Dark[]/i] (which DOES have obvious commonalities with Dissection; the band in fact became very close with Jon Nödtveidt when he was released from prison), although clearly neither inspired me enough to buy them yet. I will probably do so eventually, especially if I stumble upon them cheap.
Frankly, these last two albums likely show more of what Watain truly is than the first two albums, which were more clearly derived from earlier works, like Bathory and Mayhem. There is certainly nothing inherently wrong with possessing the ambition to spread your art with as wide a net as you can manage; this was Euronymous' ideal. I obviously have not studied the later albums in any kind of serious depth, but certainly a less 'artistic' mindset is not necessarily a knock against the work. I respect Watain's 'commercial' ambitions, at least what I've experienced of it thus far. Nobody can rightly accuse them of not being genuine.
Frankly, these last two albums likely show more of what Watain truly is than the first two albums, which were more clearly derived from earlier works, like Bathory and Mayhem. There is certainly nothing inherently wrong with possessing the ambition to spread your art with as wide a net as you can manage; this was Euronymous' ideal. I obviously have not studied the later albums in any kind of serious depth, but certainly a less 'artistic' mindset is not necessarily a knock against the work. I respect Watain's 'commercial' ambitions, at least what I've experienced of it thus far. Nobody can rightly accuse them of not being genuine.
ASD
observing the sabbath
Thralldom
Winter of My Bliss
How is Lunar Aurora's Hoagascht compared to Andacht or any of their other music? My copy arrived today but I won't listen until tonight because I am not going to be home. I have good expectations based on their consistent discography.
Spiderchrist
The Unjesus
Mort Divine
Shrine Maiden of the In-Crowd
I don't know. Albums like Ars Moriendi are far superior than those two. If you haven't heard the album, you should give it a listen.
Mort Divine
Shrine Maiden of the In-Crowd
I do like that album and most all of what they've done, but Andacht still stands above for me.
Thralldom
Winter of My Bliss
The first two albums are really good. Someone compared them to early Abigor once in a review that I read and I feel like that is a good reference point for the sound that they have.
I can't decide what album I like the best, but Andacht is probably my favorite of their more recent ones.
I can't decide what album I like the best, but Andacht is probably my favorite of their more recent ones.
EternalMetal
Active Member
- Mar 31, 2004
- 1,843
- 670
- 113
Andacht is still better than the new one for me. Hoagascht is a little on the mellow side but still a solid album imo.
V.V.V.V.V.
Houses Ov Mercury
Hoagsacht is quite mellow indeed, esp. compared to Andacht, but they're not exactly known for releasing the same album a million times in a row.
Saparmurat_Niyazov
Member
That lineup could almost be from 1998.
I have Andacht but I've only listened to it twice. I liked it, but I'm really not interested in black metal at the moment.
Master_Yoda77
Juggalo
Similar threads
