Personally, I'm glad to see the genre start to move on from the Satan stuff. I'm not some uptight religious person, but a lot of it was cheesy, boring, and played out IMHO.
I also prefer albums and bands that have at least decent mixing and production values. Again, that is just my preference when it comes to metal.
All of that said I really like BM bands Dimmu Borgir, Immortal, Enslaved, Satyricon, and Darkthrone.
I am also really getting into Antestor, who is an unblack (or white metal, sorrow metal, or however one wants to classify them) metal band. I think that the vast majority of Christian oriented metal is terrible, but these guys are worth a look.