.... Um, I'll probably be deemed "pretentious and elitist" for pointing this out... But Renoir is pretty much the pop-star equivalent of Impressionism. He painted anything he thought he could sell--- He painted what the Academics painted but looser and quicker. That way he sold. And he sold more....
His work is shallow.
He's not a very good Impressionist.
But Monet! You're very right about Monet, he was great.
Also... Do you by any chance know anything about any other period of art history? I'm curious, because people always seem to know the Impressionists, but little else.
You live in NYC, so you must have been exposed to plenty other things---- But you still like Renoir best eh? =/
Yup your elitist lol jk... But anyways Renoir was commissioned by the rich to paint them paintings (though not all his paintings) so that is why alot of his subjects in his paintings were high society. But nonetheless Renoir was more famous for his use of color then what subjects he painted about.
Also imo Monet was a bigger star but not by much then Renoir. Nonetheless Renoir and Monet are my two favorite painters for their use of color (Impressionism) and not for what they painted. I don't know if you seen their paintings in person but if you did you would see that photographs of their paintings in books do not do their paintings justice.
Anyways I like artists from other periods as well Da Vinci, Vermeer, Rembrandt, Caravaggio, Goya, Caspar David Friedrich (love his painting: The Stages of Life),Frederick E. Church (check out his painting: Twilight in the Wilderness),James Abbott McNeill Whistler, Max Liebermann, Robert Henri, George Bellows etc.. etc...
I have alot of different tastes in art... just that Impressionism is my favorite.... I hate anything modern or contemporary... I don't even consider it art... i went to MOMA and saw a canvas painted completely Black... that is not art.. that is crap... anyways i been to enough museums in NYC to tell you which ones i like and which ones I don't... one small museum in NYC alot of people are not aware of that I like is this one:
www.frick.org
But anyways wish you could of seen the Monet exhibit I was talking about Susperia.. it was in a Gallery and benefited Breast Cancer research and such... they had actual letters of Monet to his wife (not that I could read french lol but they had translations as well), rare photographs of Monet with people throughout his life, alot of his paintings but especially the two paintings that have never been seen in public or in books... I can look up the titles of the two paintings from the book I bought at the exhibit (cost freaking $80) and let you know... perhaps you can find them somewhere in the internet from the titles i give you...