I have been thinking about updating my criticker so Barthalen and whoever else follows me doesn't think I'm dead. Still, since I moved to letterboxd I'm not sure why you prefer criticker. Letterboxd has all the informal joke reviews of criticker but also a lot more long analytical ones, and a bigger userbase overall.
there’s stuff i prefer about letterboxd don’t get me wrong, but things i like about criticker are:
- it seems almost completely immune/oblivious to developments of the last 10-15 years. there’s none of that woke circle jerking social media aspect and i swear everyone on there is over 30 years old, whereas everyone on letterboxd is 17 and probably posts on instagram about how based ocasio-cortez is (slight generalisation). it’s nice to get a break from that whole vibe sometimes.
- it’s by far the best recommendation engine that exists anywhere. scarily accurate (and customisable) algorithm, fully filterable database catered to you, i’d absolutely kill for a music version. i’m not sure if you’ve ever had enough ratings to feel the full benefit of this, i think once i started pushing over 1000 it really started to get me, and these days it’s eerie how well it knows me sometimes.
- i think there are more users on there whose tastes truly interest me, although a lot of them don’t/rarely review sadly. my network on there is definitely more knowledgeable and less inclined to buy into hype and such. plus iconogassed is my favourite movie person to the point that i have all his high end ratings saved in case he or the site ever vanishes.
- it’s super autist friendly of course. i love all the little statistical stuff you can play with as a premium member. and i love being able to fuck around with my scale, if you couldn’t tell.
- i also like how the site is run; there’s no cunty moderation (unlike letterboxd which has caused loads of people to leave), they fix bugs really quickly, they do so little to force subscription on you that it’s easy to not even know it’s an option. nice layout too for the most part imo, not as good as letterboxd but better than fucking rym or whatever.
- i’ve had pm conversations with several people on there like iconogassed, theficionado, paolofilmo, schnofel, mentaculus, karamazov., djross/lumpnboy, darren/seethruskin (genuinely can’t remember which creepy twin lol), etc, which isn’t possible on lboxd.