Einherjar86
Active Member
I don't disagree with anything you said re Smile. My take is that it's entirely derivative, just extremely effective in its execution. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
I still struggle with what you say about It Follows though... while you praise it for the adolescent camaraderie, for me that gave it a sense of coziness that I found out of place or inconsistent with its other ambitions. Each to their own I guess. However the dilapidated urbanism, current generations being weighed down (followed) by the previous, that's all horror trope too (Candyman to name but one).
That's fair. To just say a bit more about my own personal feelings here, as time goes on I tend to find the premise of characters turning on each other and doubting each other to be increasingly easy in horror movies; it's a way to elevate the terror/dread/hopelessness/etc., which is what a lot of horror narratives want, obviously. There's something about a narrative in which characters simply believe one another that I find a) counterintuitively subversive (for a horror film), and b) endearing in an unexpected way.
Really good point about urban decay in horror, you're totally right; I just found the specifically post-2008 subtext in It Follows to be more contextually poignant, rather than reflecting a more general impression of urban decay in America (it's been so long since I've seen Candyman, and I haven't seen the remake yet).
My memory is that it fell apart in the final act.
I recall reading the director saying that an idea for a sequel would have been for the protagonist and friends to track the entity back to where it began by searching for the people who passed it on. My thought was that that would have been a really fucking cool way to conclude the film, although it probably would have made it super long.