oh he's capable of diversity and great presence and nuance but i dunno, he seems to have lost it. every time i see him these days he either seems like he doesn't give a shit or he's trying too hard (or both, i.e. 'the illusionist'). quite liked him in '25th hour' though which is vaguely recent.
edit: was just reading a 25th hour review and came across this: 'But Norton is increasingly an actor swallowed whole by his self-satisfaction and never quite finds the rhythm of his character. He lacks the potential energy he once exhibited in uneven work like American History X and Fight Club, content to float on a toxic cloud of early promise and late arrogance.'
i can actually see how that applies in other films more than that one.
the others you listed are all p great (saw ejiofor in redbelt recently and thought he was excellent - as was the film actually), man i love PSH. add damien lewis to that list.
speaking of great performances and TDK, i'm glad people are starting to come around to the idea that eckhart was better than ledger.