Einherjar86
Active Member
The original Hellenistic sources include many eyewitness sources written by Alexander's top staff, such as Ptolemy I. A pity they're all lost now.
Or are you simply anti-historicism/historiography?
I forgot about this! After re-reading these posts, I can only assume that I missed your comment about the Hellenistic sources being lost last time.
My impression had been that the Hellenistic sources were heavily biased/romanticized, and so we had to rely on later Roman sources. My rejoinder was merely to ask whether later "unbiased" sources are any better since their historical removal would suggest (to me) that, even if unbiased, they don't have the immediacy that Hellenistic sources would.
But if the Hellenistic sources are all lost, then it doesn't matter either way. So apologies for the misunderstanding. I'm actually incredibly interested in historiography, primarily as it relates to narrative form.