the first 5 are all 5 stars, the last 3 4 and a half stars. they are all pretty damn solid.
To give a better impression of how good the songs are, my top 10 opeth song list
1.Harlequin Forest
2.Blackwater Park
3.The Moor
4.Isolation Years
5.The amen corner
6.Under the weeping moon
7.Advent
8.beneath the mire
9.The funeral portrait
10.The leperaffinity
top 3 albums:
MAYH
SL
GR
I can hardly figure out the lyrics, and I certainly haven't found soem kind of concept. But it satisfies you - the record I mean. Per is a GREAT addition and bass is really audible and the super short solo on atonement is Mikael's (or peter's?) best.