No, I wish they were, then life should be really easy. You must understand that we "old" metalheads are not as music-wise as you NIN fans are, so I come here in hope that some of your wisdom will reach me.
But, you know, there are some degrees between Anders and Sinatra or Celine Dion. And no, there's nothing worst than being a fanboy.
Wait, liking a band over the top is worse than spamming "KILL YOURSELF" under Justin Bieber videos every single day?
As for the NIN-roots, it just puts most of the criticisms here in a pre-historic perspective. NIN returns from the long hiatus with a strange record and very poppy songs. Two years later they release an electronic heavy album, most of the stuff were composed on a laptop. 2 years later they release an instrumental album than 2 months after that they release an album for free, which sounds like garage rock, with raw instruments. Then you go to live shows and every song sounds different and more energetic, older songs are remade or mashed up, etc. But we appreciate it greatly, the sheer versatility of Trent Reznor is something truly fan.boy worthy.
And there are the IF fans, who lose their shit because SC is somewhat softer than the previous album, even though every goddamn album since 2000 had at least that big of a difference compared to the previous one. It's like time passes slower here, or I dunno.
There's NIN where Trent does falsettos, and most of his older material includes heavy shouting. No one cares if he can't give back those falsettos live (there is even a huge fan favorite song which he has never played and probably never will, because it's actually too hard to sing live, and sounds shitty according to him), no one cares if he can't scream like 20 years ago, the man is 40+, we don't find it hard to give him a break, he does the best he can and there were instances where he actually improved his voice in later years, so it's not even a steady decline.
Meanwhile Anders' sings almost the same (I read the threads here from 10+ years ago, people were bashing him for his voice, haha), but it's still hard for you people to come to terms with it.
Of course, NIN fans have their dark side as well. First of all, there are a few people like you, or let's say like those who can't seem to be satisfied with anything here. They want the [insert specific NIN album here] sound badly. But they are pretty much ridiculed and made fun of, so yeah, the community hates them. We are incapable of appreciating what we are given. NIN has one of the most varied and colorful setlists out of any band in the world, but since we are accustomed to that, we always make over the top expectations. "Oooh, why don't they play this and that instead of those? Yes-yes, they should mix this with that, make a special intro and.. and .. and... " yeah, but at the end of the day you go to their show and enjoy it all the same. Trent has a charisma as well, though he's not the crowd hyper like Anders'. Anyway, it's not like Trent can sing well, if you listen to a random NIN song, chances are, he doesn't even sing. He speaks, he speaks loudly, he shouts, he makes random fucking voices. It's really rare when he actually sings, he just have a nice, characteristic voice, you enjoy listening the music he crafts with. Also, he has pretty good lyrics - aside from some facepalm worthy ones, haha. Anyway, I never read NIN fans crying about how he is a mediocre singer. We all know it, it's a fact, and if you gonna bring it up every goddamn fucking day, chances are, most of us would consider you a simple hater.
Meanwhile every turn Anders dares to open his mouth he meets with the most asshole comments from here. Damn dude, you still don't like how he sings! Amazing, I wonder if tomorrow's show will change that! Not? Well, maybe the one after...
Since NIN is pretty much one man, we learned to respect him as an individual. He is a breathing living person with his own personality, which we like. I mean, if you hate the one guy who makes up the entire band, why are you still with him, right? He has his stupid moments, but this post is already lengthy enough, so I won't give any specific example. Anyway, we call him out badly and there are heated debates over at NIN boards, but then again, we are arguing about his actions as a person, and not about "omg, this guy is still small wtf #2014".
IF are money-whore sellouts, Anders can't sing and who gives a shit if he is a great crowd pleaser, Björn ruined the whole band, is there any lower???
I'm not saying everyone is on board with every single new NIN material, and the ones who were young during the Broken-TDS era will most probably always find those songs their most favorite and so on, but they either dropped the band after the changes (even Broken-TDS was a change though), or still dig the new stuff. Or they don't dig them, but they still go to live shows, because that's a different experience.
To give you perspective: NIN song 1:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MeoyOIRIeHs NIN song 2:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EDQLVLsrnv8
I'm not crazy, so trust me when I'm telling you there are shitton of people who go apeshit if they hear either of these live.
Meanwhile Anders opened his mouth in 2000, especially in 2002, and the controversy is still raging on, haha. I totally get it if someone is a metalhead and feels that IF is not his stuff anymore, but then he has absolutely no reason to be here. Like, all of you who are acting like SC is some kind of controversial album (after SOAPF... ok), you know as well that 5 years and two new albums from now, you will do the same, except with that album. "Maaaan, at least Siren Charm had it's moments, but this new album!! Holy shit, is it just me or does Anders struggle with the cleans here? Compared to this, SC was pretty ok".
My wisdom? If you don't like something, stop listening to it. Changed my life. If you don't like something in live version, don't watch videos about it. Especially if you don't like them either way, just turn it off.
and
sing
that
I AM THE GREAT DESTROYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEER
pewpewpepew shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh boom boom peeeeeeeeeew
Just kidding, don't do that, live version is much better. No hats or glasses either. He hits most of the notes as well, though the lyrics are like 1/4th of the live version and most of it are spoken.