I thought it was very good as well, and I've every movie, episode (well..of TOS), etc.....
Some complaints were.... (spoilers)
...I know *why* the emphasis is placed on it being an alternate timeline, but I don't know *why*. What I mean is, although nothing as monumental as a whole planet being obliterated happened in other time-travel occurances, I saw little to differentiate the time-travel in this movie from others..... if an alternate timeline was created here, then why not in 'First Contact', 'The Voyage Home', etc? Because things still changed there, even occurances one would think are small, i.e. Earth people being aware of the Borg hundreds of years before, that can cause a huge snowball effect. So.....
Nero = average revenge guy. But, he did non-average revenge stuff....so it's disappointing he wasn't fleshed out more. You didn't really get to know him and feel him advasarial as with Khan, Chang, etc.
Nothing Nero did would have prevented a star from going supernova. Sure, a full fledged Romulan Star Empire might have taken over the quadrant by then... but still. The home planet is pretty much going to die. Fail.
Spock tosses Kirk onto an ice planet loaded with dangerous creatures rather than putting him in the brig. Red line of destiny notwithstanding (he met old Spock and Scotty, somehow, because of this).... seemed slightly out of character even for an emotionally conflicted Spock.
Spock & Uhura...what the ???? How did that happen? No buildup or anything, just..bam.
More Orion girl though, plz. Although it's a shame she's kind of a whore. But Kirk pretty much is too. Eh...
7.5/10