- Mar 16, 2009
- 2,390
- 248
- 63
Does anyone have the "Live from Popstaad 2001" show from the IF Live Collection Torrent?
Yeah. Nothing special, but the audio is pretty good indeed.
Does anyone have the "Live from Popstaad 2001" show from the IF Live Collection Torrent?
You mind if I upload the Worlds Within The Margin one? And do you know where it is? Must be USA right?
Does anyone have the "Live from Popstaad 2001" show from the IF Live Collection Torrent?
It isn’t a heavy album, despite what the abrasive riffing of “Everything's Gone” appears on the surface to be, but it also isn’t as dynamic as the soaring female vocals in “When the World Explodes” would lead you to believe. Siren Charms rather chooses to use these attributes as a veil to hide that fact that In Flames simply do not have anything left in the tanks to drive an entire song from start to finish. It’s all a garnish that attempts to mask charred, lifeless songwriting and a very acute awareness that In Flames are so far past their prime it is becoming more worrisome than humorous.
the simple fact is that there is nothing to lift up the dreary verses of Siren Charms save half-hearted melodies and solos that are both scattered and short, fleeting attempts to inject life in a sound that flatlined years ago.
These oversights show that In Flames are simply becoming lazy, because despite their ability to craft many brief but powerful melodies they somehow refuse to address errors that are repeated throughout the record.
Amidst all of this creatively barren wasteland is Anders Fridén, who once again sets the low watermark as quite simply a completely inept vocalist in all aspects, retaining a flat, wailing scream and equally screeching cleans. More often than not during Siren Charms’ many soaring choruses, Fridén forms vocal melodies that differ noticeably from what the rest of the band is doing, creating a feeling of vocal-driven music in a genre that should not be structured that way.
Rather than taking the evolution shown within “With Eyes Wide Open” and realizing that a formula that reinvents itself on the back of shifting, evocative guitar riffs is the best way to approach this “radio metal” style, they instead opt for the simpler path of tossing around chords and hoping they fall into some sort of intelligible order
Comparing to what the band has done in recent years though, Siren Charms is still an unforgivable misstep containing oversights in both songwriting and execution that such a veteran band should be able to spot and correct. They’ve had some truly excellent songs come together on their past few albums, but Siren Charms contains no such diamonds in the rough. Instead, we are aptly left with what amounts to a true siren song: a strangely appealing piece of simplistic, melodic metal that may be hard for fans to resist, but if they take the bait and dive in head first, Siren Charms will lead to nothing but savage, bitter disappointment.
Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off
kinda catchy and well-written...
Through Oblivion is so beautiful that I cried the first time I heard it....
Anders' performance is very unique, it's a good thing that he isn't emulating anyone, he's doing his own
style....
Even though they're goin for a softer sound you can hear melodeath riffs and they're kinda good, sometimes
they're too low in the mix (e.g Through Oblivion) but other than this is a very good record.
Another negative review. 68/100
"listenable", "dull", "lazy"...
68/100 is fine, especially after he was ranting for long minutes how he did not enjoy the album at all. All in all I agree with the guy about In Flames, and I like how he smashes cavemen to either accept it or stop crying, and how he emphasize new fans are MUCH more in numbers. Some much needed reality-check. Of course, our opinions on the album differ, but it's not even arguable: he felt like 2 minutes into a song he did not ever want to listen it again, I still keep coming back to almost every song, so yeah. That's him, that's me.
At least he didn't do a fake-freakout about Anders' voice when he sings like this since ASOP (and did it earlier as well), he did not pretend Through Oblivion is so not In Flames-like (Metaphor says hello from 12 years ago) and he did not expect any hardcore MDM album, he just wanted a good album which he - in his opinion - did not get.
It was the first really slow track from them (Dawn Of A New Day was more extreme, but it's "whiny" just like TO), then Evil In A Closet was maybe a step forward in terms of heaviness but then came Come Clarity to ruin hopes of IF never releasing such a song. There's really nothing special about TO.
Dawn Of A New Day was more extreme
it's about as extreme as the Backstreet Boys.
But yeah, other than both being "slow songs" Metaphor and Through Oblivion have very little in common. One is a cool little acoustic piece with questionable vocals on top of it, the other is a modern commercial rock track with questionable vocals providing the melody.
Compared it to Metaphor. TO is still CC part 2. Hell, it's less whiny in terms of singing.